"fumbles but collects it cleanly" © S. Cummings

How is that a penalty, the player has his feet on the line and strikes the arm and the saints player knocks on, that's such a BS call and cummings explanation is equally a pile of steaming turd as it's not relevant if the player is in an onside position!
Ref giving saints plenty but they don't need it as Salford are absolutely dire.

Hemmings makes so many mistakes now in commentary, every game. Time to retire.

How utterly unprofessional and cringeworthy is the patter these four come up with!? Pathetic

I've actually realised that Barrie McDermott is often the voice of reason on most incidents in games - but it's reduced to puerile banter when Eddie and co try to come back at him. There are simply too many voices vying for attention, and it's jarring and distracting.

Get rid of O'Connor and Hemmings - bring in a more polished performer for the main chair, and keep Barrie as the co-commentator; Cummings has no useful role at the moment, but that's partly because they ask him to do the impossible, i.e to interpret what a referee is thinking - so either clarify his brief, or get rid of him too.

I like Carney and Wells as summarisers - but Clark has become a parody of himself; in trying to break the stereotype and sound intelligent, he often disappears up his own grammatical fundament. Angela is full of enthusiasm, but it's like a junior players Mum doing an interview.

The whole thing is stale and amateurish.

That’s the major thing about it all, it’s amateurish

All need replacing with people with enthusiasm for the game

The Sky presentation is more listenable with Bill Arthur & Carney and Wells on commentary than the other shift. O'Connor can't hold a candle to Eddie Waring, never mind the current NRL professional commentators.

Wells is wittering on a bit in this one

I much prefer commentary with Jon Wells, Brian Carney and Bill Arther. Very refreshing without and of Terry O’Connor, Phil Clarke or Eddie Hemmings.

If thats the rugby league gene pool we are f00k3d.

I agree some new faces in the commentary box would be nice. I think both Jamie Jones Buchanan and Jon Wilkin have the potential when they retire.

For the love of RL absolutely not, they are NOT commentators, not even close.

buchanen? no thanks, want to understand the commentary

Still waiting for someone to tell him he's got his head on upside down