Pleasantly surprised by this game. Was expecting one way traffic but so far it's an enjoyable game.
Saints have been pretty fortunate with a couple of their trys and Widnes unfortunate not to have a couple more.
Saints class will show in the end I reckon and they'll get the win but I hope I'm wrong!

Credit to Widnes for their efforts so far.

oh and to note Carney is outstanding and the commentator for the game is also doing a fine job. Eddie can do one right now and get his pipe and slippers and go sit in the retirement home he should be at.
Carney rightly points out that nothing is 100% certain with a penalty try so you could never effectively give them if it's a 'would' (which is by definition an absolute) score a try and Wells is a c@@k womble with his interpretation/statement regarding a penalty try.

Widnes pooped on again with that call. Lost possession.

Absolutely shambolic, the referee has effectively swung this match with some bloody poor calls against Widnes.

With the exception of Leeds and Wakefield, Widnes have given us more of a game than anyone else. This is why I predicted they wouldn’t go down. They can and do, at times, the basics right. Well done Widnes

Regards

King James

Feel sorry for Widnes today, competed well, but were done over by some plainly wrong decisions, two try that should never have been given, one up there with the worst VR decisions I have ever seen. Not saying Widnes would have won, but the opportunity was taken out of their hands.

Widnes were good, the better team in parts but to play like that and still lose by 20 points highlights how poor they are. In all honesty they did get some tough calls go against them, on tries, but that was never a sin binning or penalty, Peyroux never touched Heremaia. I get people want the underdog to win but there were some questionable high tackle penalties as well that no ones mentioned. We were quite poor but won and no injury problems. Hopefully a Warrington win to give us a gap at the top but I’m not hopeful on that one.

You are a bell end if you don't think that was a pen and sin bin , should of been a penalty try

Just leave it at that.

I'm ok with it not being a penalty try as there is a bit of doubt there with Richardson's presence but fully agree on it being a sin bin, that was an easy decision to make. The guy above saying there was no contact needs to visit his optician.

If that was nt a penalty try's then we may as well scrap the penalty try option. Widnes scored straight after so it did not really matter, but that was a penalty try, he would have scored if he was not obstructed.

It was a dive worthy of a Premier league footballer.
He had over run the ball and a finger tip on the hip and he tumbles over.

Then a clear head shot to grace and no card at all.

If it was the other way around then you’d all be saying the opposite, there’s zero contact. If Heremaia wanted to he could have ran for the ball and scored. Instead he threw himself to the ground, never in a million years a penalty. Peyroux literally doesn’t touch him if you watch it again.

You've just tripped yourself up by admitting Heremaia could've gotten to the ball, your lame excuse is that he didn't want to.