Grade C is careless / reckless. Where does intentional start? Looked plenty of intent to me.

frustration from brough , childs waved play on when his tackle brought a knock on from tomkins , at the time giants had just got back in the game but fell further behind to a try just after that

not acceptable though to react like that, be banned for the games against fev, batley which the giants should be winning without him anyway

' reckless ' is bad technique leading with the elbow , whilst in the tackle .
' Intentional' is deliberately dropping on someone's face with it after the tackle has been made . IMHO E-F

brough charged only once in 8 years?

this his 2nd charge now, not as dirty a player as some are trying to make out

That was nowhere near as bad as I was expecting. 2 game ban at the most IMO.

Unlike most Wigan fans i doubt you'll find many Giants fans defending him, yes he was frustrated with not only our game but some of the decisions going against us and a bit of sly stuff from Salford, but that is a poor do, dropping the forearm on someone like that on the ground.
Be lucky to get away with 3 game ban, could be a blessing in disguise or could end any slim hopes we have of staying up.

Was a great tackle, perfect technique.

He's no Ben Flower. Tomkins motor functions weren't in jeapordy and he wasn't even unconscious.

Just because he hasn't been charged often doesn't mean he's not a grubby little monkey. Perfect example would be O'Loughlin.

It's got nothing to do with grades or previous, it's all about the relationship between the club/RFL and who's on the disciplinary panel. We all know the RFL just make it up as they go along to suit. My guess is Brough will get off with it and cop a £1000 for the inconvenience.

He hasn't been cited 30 times - he is in the RFL match review database that many times. Occasionally people try to trot out the number of entries in this list as if it proves something - the reality is the vast majority of things looked at by the match review panel end in no action, no further action, penalty sufficient etc. It doesn't bear any relationship to how dirty or not a player is.

He's not as good as people make him out to be. Just an opinion but he never seems to be a team player, just a glory hunter and certainly not international standard.

Maybe he should have been charged more often, I mean he put Mason Caton Brown on crutches for most of the season with his cannonball tackle at Easter, he got away scot free. Horrible little grub.

Even if he gets a 3 match ban, Hudds' fixtures coming up might not make it a critical loss as they play the 3 'unfancied' Championship clubs next.

Fev (h)
Batley (a)
London (h)

Will be back for the crunch ones against HKR, Leeds and Leigh.

Might have drawn Wane/s attention, he does like signing that type of temperament in a player.