A bit rich from someone who was advocating a second NZ team in an Australian competition after the Warriors game in Wellington a couple of weeks ago!

Kiwis make up 29% of the NRL and closer to 40% of the u20s comp down here......2 French players outside Catalans and 8 starters for the dragons is no comparison!

What the hell has that got to do with it? If NZ has that many players then it should have its own thriving competition not trying to piggy back into the Aussie competition. You can't have it both ways.

[iJust imagine if the Kiwis could sort out their own competition without having to rely on the Aussies.[/i

It is lovely in France at the moment. I am sat on the terrace with a drink in hand. If I was a bit closer to the South West I would be looking for a game.

Nope....NZ Players ply their trade in the NRL because that's where the money is. The #1 sport here struggles to generate sufficient cash or interest, so the idea of a cash rich PROFESSIONAL domestic RL comp in a country of 4 million is insanity........but France, with 66,000,000+ population and apparently a massive following for the game in the SW struggles to get anything like the attention of the other football codes. The opportunity in France is a reality, but NZ, with it's tiny population, will never be able to support a top tier competition.

Think your being unfair on the Catalan fans, its a one off visit to France for supporters from England. How many could afford to travel every second week?

think the catalans attendances are abit suspicious ... is this the old favourite 'tickets sold' attendance or the actual that turned up.

8549 last season when i went to watch Giants there and didnt look anywhere near that!

They gave away free tickets with the Union club for this game, hence inflated attendance

there you go then

Kick them out. Bring in Fev and Leigh. At least they will bring some away fans.

Isn't that an even bigger argument to say the Kiwis should stop piggy backing on the Australian competition and start their own?

So they're piggy backing on the money then? But if a French club does it, then that's wrong because they should play in their own cashless competition? Seems a bit contradictory to me.


You can quote a nation's population all you like, but if the game isn't that big there, then the population is irrelevant. Potential means nothing in the present, and if you don't make the right steps, potential will never be reached.


So because the country is so large, they are victims of being in a large area, but because NZ is tiny, it's OK for them to piggy back?

Common sense prevails fortunately.