Not sure if Charnley was in touch or not but if he'd have chased it with some bloody urgency then he would have been able to take it with ease. Looked like he was out for a casual morning jog. Infuriating!

Heres a funny idea.

england v aus = kiwi ref
england v kiwi = aus ref
aus v kiwi - english ref

Who'd a thunk it?

The ref was a kiwi wasn't he?
Hicks was English and the video UK.

We can hardly call bias.

There was clear evidence that Charnleys left boot displaces about an inch of touch line. An indentation if left on the line.

It was a close call but sadly the right ones like the forward pass is give Tomkins took near half way. It's frustrating as I saw what I considered to be several forward passes by the Aussies which never went punished.

As fans we have a duty to hound Hicks out of the game at every match he officiates in next season though, it's only fair......

It was a 50/50 call you cant really argue with Hicks whatever way he swung at least he made a decision something which people on these boards complain about, touch judges not doing this so well done Robert.

Charnley could have put a bit more in his chase back but as the pitch was clearly cutting up he maybe didn't want to fall on his face. (cheap excuse). But Edwards pointed it out in the replay of the try you cant control the officials but you can control what you do in defence and with the ball and the team as a whole should have done a lot better with conceding a try on the first tackle from a set play.

the ref let a lot of forward passes go the suddenly started spotting them , wasnt the best reffing performance , certainly in the burgees high shot incident...
will be interesting to see if anybody does get sent off this wc for a high shot after letting sam off

Sadly Mr Hicks likes to be the centre of attention, his smug grin personifies the man.

How can hicks give a decision he cannot be sure about? He's guessed that he's gone out because even on the replays it's not 100% clear if he had.

Charnley back chatting and leaving a one man overlap on the far side was very poor play.

Wasn't a fan of the ref either, although I suppose he won't be that bad when I watch it back.

The same guy didn't send Tony Williams off at Wembley

Armchair experts to the fore.

Leaguefan blindly defending officials regardless of performance to the fore.

think he got it right BUT would and aussie linesman in Australia of given it against them?!

I thought Rugby League was dead to you?