Quote Cookridge_Rhino="Cookridge_Rhino"No, according to the rules that would be a knock on. The guy you quoted and 'corrected' was actually right. A knock on is is given if the ball travels forward relative to the pitch.'"
Im not sure you are correct but I accept that may be an interpretation. Another problem with RL is the exact rules are disputed.
now that was a funny thread, come back John all is forgiven
