If you hadn't rested 5 players against Quinns you could have had racked up a few points and had home advantage against Saints. You took a gamble, it didn't come off.

If it's so brilliant why don't the fans bother to turn out and watch the plaff games? EVERY play off game has has a considerably lower attendance than a normal league game.

because finishing 1st woulden't be much of a reward under that system. Teams would be happy to settle for 4th and would rest players in the last round or 2 so that their players are fresh for the important games.

I thought the original Top 5 play off system was the ideal. It gave the right level of reward to the teams finishing higher up the table, didnt reward mediocity, produced better quality games.

I couldn't have put that better myself. A perfect and reasoned explanation of why, with a 14 team league, the team finishing top are legitimate champions. The playoffs are a load of nonsense. The current system is just a ridiculous joke for our great sport. Have the Challenge Cup, the league, and the Premiership playoffs for the top 8. How can the league champions be decided by what , in effect, is a cup competion? You could add excitement to the Premiership Trophy by letting the winners of that play in the World Club Challenge. Perhaps have a 4 team WCC.

Is there anything about Rugby League that you don't want to change?

I thought the 6 team system had 1v2 for a place in the GF with the loser getting a home game against the winner of the rest? The 5 team system was the best IMO.

8 is too many teams for a 14 team league. As big an achievement as it was for Crusaders to make the playoffs they are still a team that finished in the bottom half of the league. System needs looking at.

Well.....

I like it having 13 players?

should be top 6 imo

qualifying semi
1 v 2
winner to final, loser gets second chance
eliminators
3 v 6 loser out
4 v 5 loser out
final eliminator
3/6 v 4/5
final qualifier
loser 1/2 v winner of final eliminator

If we have to have playoffs, then the top 6 format needs to come back. With 14 teams, 6 is about right. You want the playoffs to be the elite, not the average. Everyone understood the top 6, and it was very advantageous to the top 2 which is what everyone wants so that there is more pressure on the league games. Under the top 8 format, finish 4th, win 1 game, and you get a home semi final. Totally not right.

If we have to stick to top 8, then the NRL system is needed. Personally i think the RFL will give the current system one more year then revert to the NRL system. Also scraps the ridiculous 'club call'

What should have happened this week is Saints being at home to Leeds, with the winner going to the Grand Final, and Wigan being at home to Huddersfield. Next week the loser of the Saints-Leeds game would then be at home to the winner of the Wigan-Huddersfield game with the winner of that going to the Grand Final.

It would mean a five week playoff but this way all the top 4 would get two bites of the cherry and there would be no need for the clubcall.

Ive been pushing this idea for a while top half finish is better, no repeat games and chops a week off the season with every game an eliminator, it makes a lot of sense & I'd keep clubcall.