I think Mark O'Meley has been unlucky to miss out.
I think Tom Briscoe has been unlucky to miss out.

I think the halves should have been 2 of Chase/McGuire/Eastmond, too.


Given the rave reviews from many fans on here, I'm surprised at Monaghan not being included.


The fullback spot baffles me, but it's a tough choice. Wellens is decent, but he hasn't really stood out much to me, in the games I've seen. Tomkins has been very good there, as was Roberts, but I doubt that neither have played enough games there to warrant the selection. Then who else? The majority of you on here slag Mathers off, Webb's been alright, but, like wellens, hasn't really stood out. Tansey is sometimes great, sometimes appalling (clanger-wise). Greenshields missed a lot due to his leg. Ben Jones-Bishop seemed to be doing great there before his skull injury.
It's a tricky and interesting position to pick, really.

It says a lot about how weak Super League is when a generic Aussie waster like Paat Richards is in there.

waster? seriously? top of the tries, points and goal scoring charts. equalled Farrell's points in a season, beat total amount of tries for Wigan in a season by 2 tries

yeah generic aussie waster!

I wouldnt waste time replying to him, he doesnt know anything about league and spends all his time trying to annoy Wiganers. The fact that hardly anybody has criticised the choice of Richards just backs up what ive just said.

Strangely enough all the people who think Dobson shouldn;t be in tend to be FC fans...

He's brilliant in a team that has underperformed this year and his stats back him up. Eastmond is a great player but hasn't played enough and looked injured a lot of the time. Rangi Chase can be very good but when he's not he's awful.

That generic aussie waster has won the Rugby League Writers' Association player of the year

Farrell's achievement was far greater though. You should not get fooled just by the points total. He had a lot of points handed on a plate to him as a winger. Farrell earned is fully in a much more difficult position.

Strange way of lining up, Just to get certain players to fit

FB - Sam Tomkins (Sure he been playing there for Wigan)
W - Ryan Hall
C - Ryan Atkins
C - Matt King
W - Pat Richards
SO - Rangi Chase
SH - Michael Dobson
P - Adrian Morley (C)
H - James Roby
P - James Graham
SR - Tony Puletua
SR - Ben Westwood
LF - Joel Tomkins

and also had a game more to do it in

Played. Remember when your halfbacks did that?

some very strange choices in there, wellens,senior and hall especially.sam tomkins has played very well at full back,chase and kev brown have been brilliant at stand off too, puletua has been immense when i've seen him play, and tom briscoe and riley are probably more deserving on the wing than hall, my opinion anyway