Laurie is a second row or prop forward who turns 25 later this season, so Whilst he's a newcomer in some respects he's not really a prospect in the same way that Idris, Watkins and Williamson are.

They're nothing like eachother except perhaps in vague looks.

By the way, what exactly is Idris? To cut to the chase, is he eligible for NSW or QLD? I know Daine Laurie is a Blue. I remember in an interview with (I think) Matty Johns, he was asked who he'd represent in Origin. His reply was "New Souff, man".

1 is good, but i'd like both of them. They got Inglis from us, but Inglis is a QLDer at heart, going by what he's said, so that's fair enough from my perspective, wouldn't want him in such case.

laurie is a much better player than idris.

laurie is the same kind of impact players as idris expect hes been doing the business for a bit whilst idris didnt do much last year

if people are going to make a big deal about these types of players, id pick laurie as the better one

I think they've done just as well as eachother to be honest, and Laurie has only been playing NRL for like a month longer than Idris. But the main point is they're completely different players.

Taking age into account, you'd have to say Idris looks to have the brighter future.

arent you a raiders fan?

well see on monday night the truth of that.

anyhow based on what theyve done in the nrl before this season every one is talking about laurie.

Yeah, i'm a Raiders fan. What does that have to do with my opinion on Laurie and Idris?

They just seem to roll them off on a conveyor belt or something.God knows what they feed them on over there..

raiders fans for some reason hold a big grudge re tigers for 89

and they won.

if you go on aussie RL forums all the talk is about laurie

still its your opinion

its called junior development

It's called genetics (as well as Junior development), crossing Euopean DNA with Pacific Island and/or Aboriginal DNA produces superb physical specimens.

Folou, Hodges, Hunt, Inglis etc.. et.. etc...etc..

According to the super league apologists, he shouldnt be playing. Hes too young. He wont be able to take the hits. He should be blooded gently etc etc.

the same genetics are playing in the ARU and doing SFA.

the difference is junior development

Of course junior development plays a huge part but the building blocks are there right from day one. The fact that union can't develop it in the manner that league can doesn't detract from that fact.

After one game, you have summised this how?

He is going to be special.