We have that strategy, anyone who wants a go, and has the money can enter the lower divisions.

We have that club Newcastle Thunder..........Rejoice

I don't see the game is dying? As I say many clubs are aged well over 100 years old and still going strong....

Around 1970 it looked to be dying as playing numbers dropped sharply and crowds also dropped sharply.

You must remember those days??

does that include Toulouse

I'd be genuinely curious to see how many French players played top level RL before Catalans? Only one I can really think of was Maxime Grésèque. Couldn't name one PSG player without googling it. The 1996 squad had a few French in it, the 1997 squad was pretty much Aussies/English. Since Catalans I could name at least a full playing squad of French players. So what was the 'French Game' doing before Catalans? Not knocking it, as it will have produced many amateur/semi pro players and put rugby balls in kids hands (which is the main point).



The Catalans job is to be a successful rugby league club. That's the goal of any sporting team. To be successful. During our most successful era the majority of our skillful players were Aussie/NZ. In our 2001 GF we had 8 overseas players (Withers, Vaikona, Mackay, H. Paul, R. Paul, Vagana, Gartner and Rigon). 9 English players including 3 academy graduate players (Pryce, Peacock, Fielden). Catalans in their most successful year had 9 French players in their 17 for the 2018 Challenge Cup Final (Gigot, Yaha, Simon, Jullien, Garcia, Casty, Bousquet, Baitieri, Goudemand). So Catalans had the same French players, than we had English players.....and I'm sure that's the same for a lot of teams.

The problem is France in general do not have a huge player pool, so the quality will be limited. They severely lack in halves. It wasn't so bad when Bosc was around because he was great to be fair. Now they have Fages. It's not Catalans job to better the French team. It's Catalans job to make the players they have better and if that improves the French team then great. The French team on paper has a half decent 17.

Catalans academy was shut because they can't play our academies and the academies they could play over there wouldn't help the Catalans as they wouldn't be good tests. There's loads of logistical problems with this too. Cost of travel, the players are still in education and they'd need to travel Friday or before for a weekend game so they'd miss out. For Catalans it would be money down the drain. That's why they now use Saint-Estève XIII Catalan as a feeder club from Elite One. They've already had Morgue, Romano, Séguier, Perez from there and have used them to give Di Costa and Albert game time.



In all fairness the French team aren't on our level and they never will be with only 1 professional side and 1 semi-professional side to choose players from. Let's be honest, French RL isn't going to pick players from Pia Donkeys or Avignon. France in general are years behind us in RL. It was banned over there and playing habits changed. It's getting better though. France should be competing with the likes of Samoa, Fiji, Cook Islands etc. Not the likes of Australia, NZ, England. Do you have the same thoughts about Ireland, Scotland and Wales who are absolute sh*t and barely have any actual Welsh, Irish or Scottish playing for them? I do agree that Catalans should have a moral obligation to try bring more French talent through their ranks. I'm a Bulls fan and we pride ourselves on our youth system. In an ideal world every team would have as good a youth system as we do. But some see a different way to be successful.



Toronto were never liked anyway. They had a huge backer at the time and people got y about that. Okay, hindsight is a wonderful thing but at the time a lot of fans were complaining about the travel (well it was paid for), people were complaining about not developing Canadians (well some of their clubs don't produce players even though they've had 100+ years to perfect it), they complained about buying their way to SL (they worked up the leagues rather than being parachuted in like Widnes, Crusaders etc or 'saved' by the demise of another club like Wakefield). SL chairmen were worried that Toronto would eventually take their place. Imagine if say Wakefield, Hull KR, Huddersfield, Salford went down instead of London? They never took a penny out of central funding either. But not one of the outcrys at the time were about a business model, or the financial state of the club. That only came much later.

Catalans don't need to be a draw here, we probably aren't much of a draw over there. As long as they are a draw in Perpignan which they are. They've had average crowds between 7-9k since moving to Stade Gilbert Brutus. With the most supported seasons being 2018 (9,806) and 2016 (9,764). They also took the game on the road to Camp Nou (31,555) which is the record for SL attendance. So as long as they keep doing that, they deserve to be in the top flight. That in itself could be an attractor for SKY too. In my opinion Catalan being in the competition is much better for the game as a whole.

The heartland clubs do need to strengthen and I do feel that a financially stable Bradford and Leigh would be great for SL and in a couple of years time York and Newcastle would be fantastic additions too if they keep doing the right things. At the moment those are the positives of the game.

Look, it feels like we are all going over the same ground over and over. We all have different opinions and we all interpret information in a different way, I'm assuming you're older as you referenced rugby in the 70's so I guess you were there, I'm 90's born so we are going to have different views on the game naturally anyway. So let's get back on topic and hopefully we can all be supporting our respective teams from the terracing soon. God knows I've missed the rugby!

The main reason I remember in 2005 ppl were saying Catalonia should be in SL was that they would improve the French national side like the NZ Warriors had, well that's a myth as NZ had at times a decent RL team in the 1980's. And as I suspected, Catalonia hasn't improved the French RL side.

Which people were saying this though? I think that was a question someone asked Donnyman. Was it SL who said this? The IRLF? Catalans themselves? French RL? Fans? All I know is that is wasn't part of the 'criteria' to allow Catalans into the SL. It might have been talked about in terms of a potential side benefit to having them in but it was mainly to have a French presence, French TV deal, French players, to really expand the game. And arguably they have done. There's more French players throughout the league and because of Catalans inclusion to SL there's now more eyes on clubs like Toulouse. There's more French coaches, albeit most are ex-players but by playing for Catalans it's given them the platform to coach.

I'd say French national side is in a slightly better state post 2006 than pre 2006. It's just that you see other nations progressing like Tonga but they have Aussies and NZ's playing for them who's 'heritage' is Tongan. France can only really chose French players. Until there is a couple of 'hotbeds' over there for RL (like there is here) then France only have a limited selection of players. In all fairness they won the 2018 European Championship to qualify for the World Cup too.

Sky, mainly on Boots 'n' All. But Catalonia is not expansion of RL.

I don't "Dissappear" and this comment is again more personal goading from you.

Gausch has serious money problems and you know it, and he continues to preside over a club that does not have a policy of developing French players, nor providing them with first team opportunities. Go on TRL and read Barnyia's posts about how French juniors are ignored and fringe French players only make the numbers up. Even if they get on the bench they get left there unless players are injured or tired. McIlorum tells the tale of how he'd feign tiredness to give French lads a chance.

My "opinion" for others as this isn't a private conversation, is that Gausch just wants to win games and that means not bothering with French players, and as for Toulouse if they go the nod they would strengthen by copying Catalans...

Lord help us if we are crazy enough to bring in a "French" Superleague derby where nobody on the field is French.....

Not to mention depleting the English TV deal we have by blocking English clubs from SL for that Charade over the channel......

Your absolutely right, but we have people who are somehow tickled by the idea of French clubs in Superleague as you see above. The only problem is these clubs will simply stop being "French" once in Superleague like Gausches "French" side who have been outed by French RL follower Barnyia. You can be sure if Toulouse got the nod out would go their French players for English and antpiodeans...

The fact is that for the game to survive and prosper we ideally need good International competition to attract attention. We could not get that from France, with the internationals ending up being annual hammerings of a French national squad blocked from playing at professional level and incapable of competing with games over by half time before ever lowering crowds. They were pulled.

We need to give English fans quality English content, not "French" content so that they buy the SKY subscriptions/ SKY have already warned the game if they go down the path of overseas sides then the SKY contract goes down the plughole. The game itself had to take a long hard look at itself and where is was going. The American dream was looked at and declared a dream and of no value to us here, France was also looked at and again no value there.

And it really isn't a complicated analysis, the game needs......

Paying ]TV contracts ]only the English clubs can get
Pro-Player development systems from junior to Superleague which only the English clubs run
and like it or not away fans - hence the SL are chasing the Bulls return

Three solid business reasons to go forward with SKY 2022 with an all English league which Lenegan indicated.

Big thanks for the well considered interesting post. For some time the only answer to my view that the overseas clubs would not grow the sport, but would block clubs here from being part of Superleague, thus lowering our value to SKY who benefit from English fans subscriptions, and reducing the number of clubs developing players was cheap and cowardly insults from anonymous keyboard warriors. To be honest I'm so endeared with your reply I just want to respect your opinion and thank you for that 3.19287109375:5