No 5h1t, Sherlock

Fantastic contribution as always.

stevie ward has been probably our most consistent player this year. never seems to get a mention ahead of more flamboyant players but he's been brilliant

Deffo Bateman over Farrell ( well a few over Farrell) and hill over peacock

As an FC would have like to have seen Minichello in the team along with Lineham

Realistically think he could've gone in over Taia maybe, winger was a hard one even with 2 spots but can't disagree with the choices.

From a non black and white perspective, as others have said Farrell seems the only odd selection. I know Bateman has moved around at times so maybe thats hindered his chance? Still would have picked him, much as Phil Clarke would love that.

Chris Hill may not be in the Dream Team but he should definetley be in the England team

Gee, thanks.

The choice of Liam Farrell was a shocker.

Elliot Whitehead is an incomparably better back rower than the Wigan boy.

The Irish heritage selectors must have felt that there were too many Englishmen and not enough Celts in the Dream Team.

Where are Chris Hill, Bateman and Minichiello?

it's a 13 man fantasy team, you can't pick everyone in it.

personally i would have thought, Bateman, Hill, Savelio, Wardle, Minichello, Kev brown and a few more could all have been in with a shout.

Hill has made scored more tries, more offloads, more metres, more tackles, less errors and less missed tackles than Peacock.

Fourth highest metre maker in Super League and the third highest tackler in Super League (that's some stat for a prop).

He can feel very hard done by not to have made that team.

rlBBC 'Experts' selectionsrl

Don't know how so many picked O'Loughlin tbh. And the Radio Leeds guy is hilariously biased.

Only 2 overseas ( Taia, Cuthbertson) which is nice to see from an International perspective.

Quote: CM Punk "rlBBC 'Experts' selectionsrl Don't know how so many picked O'Loughlin tbh. And the Radio Leeds guy is hilariously biased.'" Haha, he was a little Yorkshire biased last year too: www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/29175604

Quote: CM Punk "rlBBC 'Experts' selectionsrl Don't know how so many picked O'Loughlin tbh. And the Radio Leeds guy is hilariously biased.'" Haha, he was a little Yorkshire biased last year too: www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/29175604

to be fair to JD, he really only knows 3 teams and thats us, leeds and cas!
almost as bad as the biased Humbersaard lot, if either of the Hull teams win they are world beaters and if they lose they are amateur, there's no inbetween, i still laugh at that guy with the silly name saying that rervers were the real deal this year after a narrow win over us on easter monday.

everyone is entitled to their opinions of course and it makes things interesting and triggers debate. personally i don't see the fuss in George Williams, but everyone else does, or indeed, O'loughlin.

That is because fewer quality overseas players are coming to Super League. The three outstanding imports who arrived in 2015 -- Todd Carney, Albert Kelly and Terence Campese -- have been injured for most of the year. Had those three been fit all year, two of them (Carney and Kelly probably) would have held the two halves positions.