Tomkins
Hall, Reed, Yeaman, Briscoe
Widdop, Chase
Graham, Roby, Peacock
Westwood, Ellis
Sinfield

Lomax, Carvell, Morley, Wilkin

Burrow is injured!!!!!!!!!

Carl Abblett vs Ryan Atkins is the strangest decision for me...

my team

1. sam tomkins
2. ryan hall
3. carl ablett (why split up a grand final winning partnership to select jack reed?)
4. kirk yeaman
5. tom briscoe
6. gareth widdop
7. rangi chase
8. jamie Peacock
9. james Roby
10. jamesGraham
11. gareth Ellis
12. ben Westwood
13. kev Sinfield

14. gareth Carvell
15. adrian Morley
16. jon wilkin
17. jonny lomax

He generaly plays well in big games.

why? Ablett has been a revelation at centre for leeds this season. Its easy for ryan atkins to look like a beast when the rest of his team are ripping the opposition to shreds for most of the season.

Looks mostly OK but would have had Atkins, Brough and Robinson in there in place of Ablett, Lomax and Mcilorum.

I still don't understand the fuss about Lomax, Gaskell to me looks the better player. Lomax will probably turn into something with time but shouldn't be in the 17 now.

Bit harsh on Sinfield. When he's been played as a replacement hooker he's looked decent. At 6 or 13 he's struggled.

Hardly in the same league as Atkins.

Ablett

Position 4
Shirt number 12
Appearances 24
Tries 4
Try assists 10
Goals 0
Drop Goals 0
Meters 2054
Carries 292
Tackles 524
Offloads 24
Attacking Kicks 5
Runs from dummy half 14
Tackle Busts 27
Marker tackles 54
Clean Breaks 14
Forty twenty 0
Kicks in general play 5
Missed goals 0
Missed tackles 32
Errors 21
Penalties 13
Red cards 0
Yellow cards 0


Atkins

4 Position
23 Shirt number
23 Appearances
21 Tries
12 Try assists
0 Goals
0 Drop Goals
2113 Meters
244 Carries
278 Tackles
22 Offloads
6 Attacking Kicks
15 Runs from dummy half
61 Tackle Busts
38 Marker tackles
20 Clean Breaks
0 Forty twenty
6 Kicks in general play
0 Missed goals
10 Missed tackles
34 Errors
4 Penalties
0 Red cards
0 Yellow cards

Atkins is a proven failure at international level though.

What one tour? When he has improved ten fold since last year......

If thats the case then 80% of that squad have failed multiple times and shouldnt be anywhere near using your logic

Quote: ComeOnYouWolves "What one tour? When he has improved ten fold since last year...... If thats the case then 80% of that squad have failed multiple times and shouldnt be anywhere near using your logic'" He was absolutely torn apart, right decision for me. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2011 He stats don't suggest to me that he's improved 'ten fold' either.

Quote: ComeOnYouWolves "What one tour? When he has improved ten fold since last year...... If thats the case then 80% of that squad have failed multiple times and shouldnt be anywhere near using your logic'" He was absolutely torn apart, right decision for me. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2011 He stats don't suggest to me that he's improved 'ten fold' either.

20 less missed tackles for the season. 66% less missed tackles. More clean breaks, more tries. Less penalties.

Its his things like decision making have improved, did you see the match against Hull with the offload for Rileys try. Phil Clarke said that that was one of the big improvements that Atkins has made.

Why did he fail at international level? For his defence or attack? If it was his defence then thats improved, if it was his attack i would put a lot of that down to the inability of the halfbacks for him not getting the ball.

You mean 13, the position he's played at most of his career? He's got bottle, but still massively overrated IMO