Bell tackle wasn’t even remotely similar to the ones by Asiata. Embarrassing, this

This is hard to keep up with…

Saints fans saying it should be banned. Leigh fans saying it was fine. Saints players then start utilising the ‘fine’ tackle and now those saying it was fine now say it’s illegal…. Yup makes sense

FWIW it’s an awkward tackle technique but not banned yet. Very effective in stopping a charging player but can go wrong plus it looks like there’s just as much danger of a head knock for the tackler.

It’s more to do with the entitlement and hypocrisy of the Saints club more than anything else.

Spot on Willy.

Get it checked out, Cokey!

Dodgy tackle?

Bongser wishes he'd mentioned the clap. DURR!

State of this thread. Fans of tinpot nothing clubs clearly bitter, full of jealousy and envy at our sustained success.

I bet you've had one more than me terneet.

Anyroad, It's beddy byes fer Cokey now. Gud neet mucker

It’s rare I agree with Wilkin and even rarer I agree with the Sad one.

This technique (if that’s an appropriate word) needs to be banned at the first opportunity. It’s not tough, it’s at best reckless and at worst malicious. The defender is not in any sort of control and flinging themselves at lower limbs.

For one player to do it causing 4 injuries in one game to me suggests in that case, it’s more malicious than reckless. After all the publicity, the medical evidence and 2 serious injuries caused, that same player does it again the following week pretty much proves that player is quite happy with the result of their ‘technique’. Anyone who wasn’t would have made sure they didn’t do it again the following week.

Bell was just as bad, I can accept in a single instance that the player likely just got it wrong rather then went on with malice. Most players will get it wrong now and again.

The RFL need to look at this in the off season and come up with suitable wording that outlaws tackles of a reckless nature but doesn’t outlaw a good, controlled cover tackle.

Chicken Wings, cannonballs etc we’re all legal at one point. It doesn’t mean they were ever right. ‘Tackles’ like this make me cringe,

Bingo.