TJ.

Joel Monaghan while at Wire: 145 tries in 145 games.

I think you might need to check Offiah's stats. More than a try a game across an entire career!

I think you can build a pretty good case for numerous players, I would say the OP is very much baiting by saying nobody comes close.

Try tallies are all well and good but can just highlight the strength of the team/ability to get their winger in than truely judge how good the winger is. Eden at Cas is a great example of this, we know from Solomona previously that playing left wing for Cas gets you plenty of tries so it’s more the team than the individual. Would Eden get near his numbers at other clubs?

Plus try tallies are only one aspect of playing wing, granted it’s a key one but you need to do more than just finish off tries

So not Vainakolo.

So not Monaghan either.

Not in SL or the NRL though (ie the modern game).
Undoubtedly the best winger of all time in my opinion though.

If were going to delve into history, then Brian Bevan outscores Offiah in number of tries scored and average tries per game.
However, it's difficult to compare one against the other as its apples and pears. Safe to say they were the best of their particular era.
Harder to say who the best winger currently is though.

Denny Solomona?

Yes him and Justin carney had similar records at Cas.

You win only based =#FF0000solely on the criteria of 43 games. However, that doesn't justify the title of the greatest winger of all time.