Andrew Johns, Paul Sculthorpe, Jamie Lyon, Kieron Cunningham & Alan Langer are my top 5 (I think), but with Lyon, johns and langer only playing for short periods of time I'd go scully.

Jamie Lyon is not the best centre to have played SL for St Helens.

Regarding the points, there's no award for MoM in the WCC?
(Whilst I don't think he was the best SL player) Chris Joynt had a run when he won the Harry Sunderland, then the next game he was MoM against Brisbane in a WCC victory and then got MoM when we beat Wigan in the CC, which was our next proper game. What a run of form that was.

There appears to be alot of people complaining about the formula used and the interpretation of best player.

I think Bovrick has mis read the formula, MoM in GF is worth 3pts less than being named best player in the world. The Dream Team refers to SL dream team not a world 13.

Andrew Johns although a brilliant player cannot be classed as the best SL player as he only played 3 games, I would suggest the minimum criteria is 2years. It is purely based on your performances in SL which is why I dont consider Morley as he played his best stuff in the NRL.

Pemps has not proved my formula wrong, the formula is to decide the most succesful player in SL not the best.

You get more points for Winning the GF than being MoS because it is the pinnacle of the British Game. If it was solely based on individual medals then Cunningham wouldnt even be in the top 10 because he has never won a MoS, Lance Todd or Harry Sunderland. Even though he has made 6DT.

The Ryan Bailey reference on the Leeds board was purely tongue and cheek but he has won more GFs at prop than any other player and only JP has won more GF rings.

I didnt come up with the formula however I do think it does reflect the what is most important and what is hardest to win.

If anybody would like to come up with another formula which they think is weighted better please feel free. It can easily be manipulated to suit players of different clubs but I think this is a fair assessment.

Johns, Vainikolo, Menzies, Stacey Jones, Cunningham, Scully, Jason Robinson, Renouf, Lam.

These are the best players I've seen in SL.

bull. Johns only played one great game on his debut. was not in the game in the play offs against Hull. nothing more than a publicity stunt.
Lyon excellent player but one great season and one ok season.

Maybe, but the question was the best player, not who has played the best in Super League.

Andrew Johns is a legend of the game, his skills are unquestionable and his career stands for itself. That he didn't play several seasons or several great games for Wire doesn't detract from him being probably the best player to ever play in SL.

As a Wigan fan I would have Barrett up there. When he was on fire he was unstoppable.

Obviously you have Scully, Farrell, Cunningham, Long, Robinson, Jones, etc who were great players and great servants of the game, but none of them were as good as Johns, who competes with Wally Lewis, Hanley, etc as some of the greatest in the history of RL.

[i**forget most of that, he's gone and amended the criteria**[/i

I have altered the question to avoid confusion! It is only based SL performances and there is a 2year minimum playing time to qualify. Andrew Johns was awesome but a couple of performances doesnt make you the best ever in SL.

Leeds maybe not have had the best individuals to play in SL but its a team game so that doesnt really matter, but what the results do highlight is Saints dominance in the CC in the SL era. Up until 2007 no non saints player would have got close to the top 3 but subsequently JP has won 4 GF a WCC and a LL.

Nobody was seriously suggested Bailey was the best prop in SL just that he has won more GFs as a prop than any other. Fielden is the most successful prop in SL history with 4GF, 2CC, 4LL, 3WCC and 2 DT giving him 95pts. Bailey has 70pts with 5GF, 2LL and 2WCC.

What about players who didnt play for the best teams. The scoring criteria doesnt help them.

Gardener at Saints is probably one of the best wingers ever if you use scoring criteria but when you have played in a great team with brilliant centres inside you you will look good.

Why are people suggesting Andrew Johns? Are you suffering from pedantry overload because the last time I looked Johns didn't inspire any Super League teams to any trophies during this time here. Saying he's the greatest player to ever play in Super League would be like saying because Peter Falk appears in [iThe Player[/i he's the best actor in it.

He played in Super League didnt he? The question was the best player to play in Super League not the most successful.

Andrew Johns far exceeds the ability and quality of any other player i have seen in Super League.

Gardener at Saints is probably one of the best wingers ever if you use scoring criteria but when you have played in a great team with brilliant centres inside you you will look good.'"

Just noticed the new "criteria".

If it was just players who had played in SL for 2yrs+ i would say Morley for how i went on at the Roosters. But based on SL performances alone, it has to be Kieron Cunningham.

I have subsequently changed the question so it is purely based on SL performances. On this basis Johns and Morley wouldnt be classed as the best ever as they played the best rugby in the NRL.

It's tragic when you have to go into that level of detail for what is a pretty straightforward question.

Going from this points system, Ricky Bibey is a better player than most in super league. This shows the most decorated player and not the BEST player. The most Decorated player to play in Super League was Edwards.

The best player was probably Andrew Johns.