I don't think anyone who sat in the stands or on their sofa can question Tomkins' commitment. he set himself to take the ball. it moved, which is why it looked like he didn't fully attempt.

No ball is uncatchable, commentary on sky is an absolute joke, I cringe when PC pipes up, Carney is the only guy on that gantry with an ounce of relevant RL knowledge.

Don't tell Clarkie he will slit his wrists

clark just chunners on with inanely his timing is woeful he refuses to let go of his little ramble even when there is an intense period of play requiring incise and accurate commentry

Surely any falling ball is falling at some angle or other, or the kick would have been made from the catcher's position?
You are Phil Clarke and I claim my £5.00.

Completely agree and how long did he have to set himself for it?.. and lets face it he was under no pressure at all.

Dont know about the No Pressure,,!It was a great kick,but its Clarkey who comes out with the drivel...

I've grown to love Sam during the 4Nations, but Clarke's fawning over him was embarassing, as is the insitence from people on here that it was uncatchable.

No ball is ever uncatchable if it's close enough to hit you when you aren't really moving.

He just had a bad game, it's a shame but it's not something that requires us to fabricate excuses for him. He'll have bad games in the future as well and he's no doubt set himself up for a season of pressure from bombs on the last.

For all the hype, Tomkins is a weak player at international level. Yes, he can run a bit but compared with a young Darren Lockyer he's a joke. We need to keep things in perspective. He's the best prospect we've had in the back-line for a while but he's along way from being a great international player. He still needs to improve on some of the basic skill of the game.

Clearly you have never been under a high ball in a spiral coming down.

A high ball usually goes vertical from the boot and drops straight down.

sam clearly positioned himself to catch the ball,by the time he 'd realised he'd completely got it wrong it was to late and he was half a metre away from it.theres no defence he messed up under the high ball and not for the first time in this series.Stop making excuses for moments of mediocrity.

It was a poor attempt by Tomkins, who looked like a rabbit in the headlights all night.

Phil Clarke is so biased towards Wigan that his position as a pundit should be untenable.

"Do you know Eddie...if you look at the stats you can see that zero percent of players caught that ball at that time, thus proving that no one could have caught that ball.....blah, blah, blah"