For the purpose of this, lets put aside the top 5 or 6 clubs becuase they'll always be the top 5 or 6 and historically always have been and look at those below them.
So...
Quote: SmokeyTA "It is only working for a select few, realistically only a few (in the scheme of things) are affected by it.
'"
I'd disagree, there are adds and omits to the arguement but on the whole personally I disagree. The best part of SL this season was the odd game and the last fortnight. After that I found it pretty dull and of low standard which after 30 years watching the game leaves me asking why. Maybe I've just got bored of it!
But, the bottom half of SL are technically trading insolvent whilst the middle tier between SL and grassroots is totally on its backside.
The interest from both supporters and sponsors is next to dead at that level, apart from the GF even Sky can't be bothered showing it anymore. This leaves ambitious clubs with little chance of building a platform and average clubs linking up with bugger SL clubs as a cheap way of making their squad numbers up. Given it's in many instances the foundation to top flight RL, it's foolish to ignore it's predicament.
Quote: SmokeyTA "
If we use Cas as an example then yes, they are a ‘decent’ sized club who cannot compete currently, financially, with the top SL clubs, and yes, they may need to ‘overspend’ to keep up. '"
So happens when the gravy runs out? Not just Cas (apologies Cas fans for using you as an example!), we could list half a dozen others. We're trying to get financial stability in the game, you more than anyone beat the drum about clubs being better managed thus warranting their place in SL. By your own admission here, that's clearly not happening and defeats the whole object of it all.
Quote: SmokeyTA "
BUT, and it is a big one, where is the logic that cutting their income, cutting their attendances, cutting their visibility etc is going to give them that platform?
'"
That's the whole point, inversely, they (and others) are not competing as it is so what's lost? Sometimes what is spent does not equal value for money.
I'm not convinced if they cut their spending by (say) 40% that it would necesarily result in a 40% drop in standards. For example, Championship wages have halved over the last couple of years but the players are still there. After Uncle Des stopped throwing silly money about at Barrow, Steve O'Connor and a few others got together and said this has to stop.
Now we have the likes of Leigh, Fev, Fax keeping their spending at more realistic levels so what we dont have now is an abundance of part time players/Aussies/journeymen earning £30k a year, average salaries are now at less than £10k. The same players are still playing aided and abetted by dual contracts and loans.
Would it not go the same in the mid to lower levels of SL, where very average players dont earn the £40-60k they are now (as quoted by Sean Long at a recent event) but earn more realistic salaries?
It's a bit of tough love granted, but something has to be done. With it, the morbid/joyous interest generated by P&R is there, Sky remain there, competitive derbies still exist, pro rugby still exists, the big clubs are still there, and financial stability has a greater chance of prevailing.
Quote: SmokeyTA "
Yes they can cut their costs, but this whole idea the whole two leagues of ten idealogy is based on an assumption that it would be more profitable for Cas to be playing in a 2nd tier, chasing promotion, and fighting against relegation in the top tier, than it is right now for them, when there is a very good chance that, even though Cas are spending less on players, and winning more games against a lesser opposition, that they also lose more fans, more sponsors, more visibility, more corporate attendees etc etc etc, That is why the idea wont work. Cas are better financially, at the moment, as the little fish in a small pond than they would be as a bigger fish in a small pond.'"
From memory, as well as taking over 10000 to Headingley for the GF, Cas had just as many (if not more) watching them in the Championship (regular crowds of 6, 7000) than they did last season so I'm not convinced on that one. Then again, P&R existed
4.75537109375:10