Thouroughly enjoyed that game. Well done Rovers.

You can tell the so called hull fc fans on hear, not the good ones who tell a game has it is you sir should shut up or go home now

Well I enjoyed it.

Yes, really. To be clear, Rovers were the better of two poor sides; I never said different. But poor it was. Later I watched the Cowboys take on the Broncos in the Queensland derby. Now there was a quality game of footie, with some great play in attack and defence by both sides. You might want it watch it to remind yourself what's good rugby league and what isn't (and don't get me wrong; I've watched some stinkers in the NRL this season too).

And I make no apologies for hoping that the rare opportunities for live rugby league on free-to-air TV produce a better game than that, whether they feature the team I support or not.

Not a great spectacle but a fantastic win for the Robins never the less! Cup games are often tight, tepid affairs as neither side wants to lose more than they want to win seemingly. Theres nowt' you can do about it, if a side turns up playing to avoid defeat rather then going all out to win, I actually thought KR played reasonably well, the Pies were very dissapointing.

I'll take a scrappy 16-12 win over a fast flowing, skilled entertaining 16-12 defeat every time.

Can this thread be renamed Wigan disgrace in view of this weeks games???

No, because Wigan lost to a champion team that is going to go places fast if Todd Carney, Scott Dureau, John Zebolon Ta'ia and Morgan Escare are not injured. Wigan is a mediocre team, while Catalans at full strength is a champion team.

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Hull KR put up a good fight against Leeds considering that they were without star players Albert Kelly, Dane Tilse, Mitchell Allgood, and Shaun Lunt. Moreover their goal kicker Joshua Mantellato was unable to convert any of their four tries. If he had been successful they would have been on 24 points and in the lead at half time. Hull KR were not disgraced against Leeds. In fact the Hull KR team should be proud of their performance given their dreadful injury problems.

Mantellato didn't attempt to convert four tries. Don't you know anything?

Mantellato has been the goal kicker all year. A natural assumption is that he would have attempted the conversions against Leeds. So you tell us what happened then smarty pants.

I've already told you, he didn't miss 4 attempts.

Dixon kicked one