I presume you mean not. Smith has to be, kicking out like that in such a mard reaction deserves the red just because of how big a spoilt baby he was. Tomkins is just out of control. He hadn't even got a clue what was going on there, and just mindlessly attacked the stray Widnes player after deciding that attacking the big group of big Widnes players celebrating wasn't a good idea. It's a good job there were no cheerleaders or mascots about or I think they would have copped one as well.

Wigan need to look at Wane's coaching and decide if the reputation of the club is worth anything to them. They are a recipe for disaster, a gaggle of mindless thugs would up like caged animals by Wane.

Smith should have got a red imo . 1st game in and it's all about the ref !.

Smith should of been red, Tomkins should of been sin binned. I don't understand how it could be any different. I get they're frustrated but you'd of thought with the spotlight on Wanes tactics they should of kept their cool. No excuses otherwise

Congratulations Widnes, I didn't give them a chance at times during the game and they battled through.

The annoying bit is that he'll escape a ban because he was yellow carded and missed the kick off.

Matt Smith should have got a straight red for that kick on the Widnes player. That IMO was more deserving of a red than Ah Van's red card

looooooool at this thread.

Swinging arm with a closed fist to the jaw of a player that put him out of the game with concussion is definitely not a sending off but a mild trip on a player definitely is one. Class.

Disgraceful from Child. Wet himself in the first half with Ah Van sending off, which given the new rules on sin bins is even more ridiculous, then lost his bottle.
Smith should've been red and Tomkins a yellow. Plus maybe a yellow for the Widnes player that ran in.
Plus a yellow for Farrell in the first half and at least a yellow for Clubb for a cannonball tackle in the 2nd half.

Utterly ridiculous from Child.

Turned out it was a crazy end to the game. When I loook to see who's reffing us, I feel nauseous when I see his name as ref.

Your last word, none of that at wigan!

Was only listening, but it sounded like there was a yellow card after the try was scored?

If that was the case, surely it's 2 shots at goal not one.

Like I said not seen it only listening.

Yes missed the word in my shock whilst typing it out. The late charges on the kickers are also looking like no accidents either.

Hahahaha yea loads of class in Hull isn't there

It's James Child again, how is he a top flight ref. It wasn't a particularly tough game to ref, but he made it look that way.

At least with Silverwood, Thaler, Bentham.......they've have had their shockers but I've also seen them have very good games. Not once have I seen Child perform well yet he still is given good gigs, dare I say it's probably the RFL not wanting to look homophobic by not picking him for key games......because his performances have NEVER warranted it.

Delusion and denial still reign at Wigan then.