i thought he had an excellent game,he let it flow and let the players do what they do best unlike some refs who seem to think they are the stars of the show and it made for an end to end game played at a furocious pace.

Thought he had a good game.

But swear he sent Creagh off late in the game for holding and Creagh remained on the paddock.

Did he referee it in a Northern Hemisphere 'style' (unlike some officials I could mention ...) ?

So if the overhead shot showed it wasn't forward, why don't they start going to the screen for forward passes?

In that he never penalised Wigan but did their opponents for the exact same things? Yes.

didn't think he did too bad, let a few things go when he should have blown but all in all not a bad showing from him, apart fom his constant wailing that is.

This was the biggest game he's ever going to ref as he's never going to get the world cup final as the Aussies wouldn't let him so he was probably very nervous before the start.In the end he did good and nothing he did changed the outcome of the game so why are people complaining about him.

Was at the game today, did okay but missed some niggling at the play the ball and around the ruck.

sam tomkins again???

The only niggling was from Tomkins trying to get a free kick!

A what???

I thought he had a really good game. Only mildly embarassing scenes came as he was attempting to explain his decision to the Australians in a Frenglish accent.

The forward pass wasn't forward.

No complaints from me, thought he did well.