At this time of the season, who would you select as man of steel for 2012. I cant really think of anyone who has really impressed? Of course, sam tomkins is having a great season but its too predictible imo.

Who would you pick and why?

Steve Menzies...still playing superbly well in a very good Catalans team,ultimate pro and not a niggly little $hit.

so just because sam tomkins is by far the best player in the league he shouldn't win the player of the year award? I see where you're coming from but it seems a little harsh

Either Tomkins or Holdsworth for me.

I don't.

I don't agree with it but can see it happening, it did last year.

Ben Westwood?????

Sam Tomkins by a country mile.

Clark Kent.

Tim Smith and Paul Aiton have gone really well this year in a revamped Wakefiled Team.

Lee Briers and Brett Finch have been vital to Wire and Wigan respectively

But i think tomkins has it in the bag

So this is now the 'player playing most above the level of what we expected of them at the start of the season' award?

If Tomkins doesn't win it, I'll be embarrassed for the players in SL as a whole.

Tomkins doesn't have a god given right to win. He has been on of the better players though. For me Scott Dureau has been superb and would get my vote. Tomkins & Hock have also been great at Wigan. I also have been extremely impressed with Paul Aiton.

Willia Isa - end of!