How many times did he change his mind tonight and how did he miss the forward pass off Hansen for Carmont's try?

The look on the St George player's faces was a picture when he was talking to them!

Thierry Alibert

and ?

and what?

this tme last week the majority seemed to be bemoaning his appointment as match ref - I for one thought he did well - he was fair and for the most part consistent in his decisions - well done M.Alibert

I thought he had a good game.

Did you see the forward pass? Did you hear him shout "play on", then say no "held, release" and then penalise the defender?

Wouldn't like to see him have a bad game!!

Overhead shot showed it wasnt



Thought that was his only mistake

There wont be a referee that has a faultless game... EVER.

I'm still undecided about that 'forward' pass... I thought it was miles forward at first but on the replay I thought it MIGHT have been flat.

Generally though I thought he had a good game.


*Edit*

Just watched the 'forward' pass again and I reckon it was flat.

he's had plenty of those,like any other SL ref - but I thought he did ok this evening

bien joué Thierry

i thought he had an excellent game,he let it flow and let the players do what they do best unlike some refs who seem to think they are the stars of the show and it made for an end to end game played at a furocious pace.

Thought he had a good game.

But swear he sent Creagh off late in the game for holding and Creagh remained on the paddock.

Did he referee it in a Northern Hemisphere 'style' (unlike some officials I could mention ...) ?

So if the overhead shot showed it wasn't forward, why don't they start going to the screen for forward passes?

In that he never penalised Wigan but did their opponents for the exact same things? Yes.