Quote: Pumpetypump "I remember reading something really disturbing about Shontayne Hape that the cumulative effect of his concussions were that sometimes an innocuous tap to the head would have a huge effect. Ultimately he retired due to the memory loss, migraines and depression that sustained concussion and heads knocks can lead to.'"
Well that's a good point and when you think about this debate that has rolled on for years, but is now coming to a head (no pun intended at all) all three forms of "Football" are in the proverbial as regards long term player welfare.
Yes I saw the Union piece showing front rowers banging their heads into each others shoulders on scrum practice.
I also have followed the soccer problems that are coming to a head. It was noted that soccer keep on kicking the ball down the road on this. Graham Souness suggests this is because they have no solution that is workable, hence there is no evidence of a single report on a trial soccer game without heading.
We don't head and now we don't scrum which I hope will be a permanent thing. But what I hate in our game is the sight of players being taken off after head knocks to be assessed by the Doctor to see if they can carry on - great when they do, but sad when they don't as we now know, that an element of irreversable damage has been done.
What's even more upsetting in our game is how certain players receive more head injuries than others, and I mean ball playing half backs, or sometimes ball playing loose forwards getting clobbered high. We have to hammer that out of our own game.....