Watch the documentary on I player
RIP Don Fox

The ruck is far messier now.

Yep, but player she the next just got tackled got up and carried on, very little laying on or slowing down but attackers genuinely just tried to get up no wriggling about trying to milk a penalty, one of the only penalties at the play the ball was a Leeds player pushing the defender at marker.
Time we started reversing plenalties for milking it would soon stop.

Another thing the caugh my eye was how fast the game went, not to actual speed if play( which was considereably hindered by the 3" on standing water) but the actual game which flowed quicker, less stop start and everybody just got on with the game, if the ball went in touch the scrum was formed so quickly and ball straight in and out (ish) if there was a turnover just hand the ball over and off we go.

It is the most iconic sporting occasion for the human drama of the missed kick and the drama of the luck that went back and forth due to the appalling weather conditions.

I was at the match and the TV pictures in the first half do not show the difficulties the players faced from the very start.

Had you seen the way Leeds played in good conditions under Roy Francis you would see how it puts to shame the modern version of the game. We seem to have lost speed in favour of power and balance and footwork has been replaced by athleticism. This has meant we no longer have any decent backs as they now all play like second rowers and explains why Barba looks so good giving us a reminder of how the game should be played.

Kicking long in those conditions was exactly the right tactic.
The weather took the "bar of soap" analogy to a whole new level.
The kick off and score with a minute to go was an excellent bit of ingenuity and Fox certainly didnt deserve to be on the losing side.

I was lucky enough to see some of those blokes play. Not quite old enough to have seen Bev Risman but he managed to look classy even in those conditions.

There was so much more space then. There was also less people in the tackle meaning getting your hands free and offloading was far easier. The idea that a modern player like Watkins, Shaul, George Williams, McGilvery or Hall wouldn't have been a star back then is crazy. I'm sure some of the stars back then would also be stars today as well, but let's not pretend the skills coaching back then was ahead of today because it simply isn't.

What I find really noticeable watching games from whenever way back when up until the mid 80s is just how relatively small players were, in terms of general body shape (except for the obviously fat gets running around most clubs). Backs were generally small and hardly any of them looked like they'd last five minutes in the modern game without being snapped in half. Most of the backrowers would get absolutely totalled if they played today and props from contested scrums were generally hopelessly unfit.

Its just such a different sport back then - far less physical (except for the gratuitous violence), some skills far poorer like long passing and kicking, but other skills far better like off the cuff plays and the willingness to take risks. I like watching games from the 80s and 90s but its a very different spectacle. I've got a DVD of the Broncos GF wins we watch every now and then, and the earlier games seem very fast, and I'm always quite surprised to see that if anything there were fewer tackles made than today, when the game just seemed to crack on at a rate that feels much faster.

I remember the back end of the era of contested scrums and they were always a mass of struggling players trying to bend the rules to get possession. It was a lottery to try and officiate them. The play the ball nowadays is like that.

I wonder if the cause of the problem with the wrestling and buggering about at the play the ball is down to the 10m rule. When players only had to get back 5m there was less need to wrestle and hold down so it didn’t happen.

I know what you mean but I think the wrestling would still happen, I think it’s just a consequence of professionalism and modern conditioning that means clubs have the opportunity to practice the wrestle/control of the tackle more than they used to. Without going back to the amateur/semi pro days I don’t think we’ll ever eliminate the wrestle. I think we can tidy it up, mostly by controlling the attacker at the play the ball, ensure they’re stood up before playing the ball, facing the right way, touch the ball with their foot and don’t step off the mark.

I think if we had defences at 5m now you’d have attacking teams going backward in sets. Defences can legitimately be up on first receivers by the time they get the ball even at 10m. With 5m it’d be a nightmare.
I’d make a couple of rule changes:
- Alter the held call so that when a player is held the referee controls the speed of the play the ball. Currently there’s no incentive for the defence to hold the ball carrier up because they can then play the ball very quickly. This leads to defences holding the ball carrier so he can’t offload but delaying putting them to the ground for as long as possible, then dumping them to the ground. I think a rule change where defences can actually benefit from holding a player up would both slightly speed the game up and cause fewer injuries.

- change the point at which defences can move up. Currently it’s when the ball carrier touches the ball with his foot at the play the ball. I’d move this back to when the acting half back either runs or passes. It would give the attack a smidge extra time on the ball each tackle, hopefully opening the game up just a little.

I did think the same TBH when watching it. When you watched the footage of the players just getting on with it in several inches of standing water, and you see the modern day lot just flapping round on the floor like a caught fish begging for a penalty, you realise how desperate we are as a sport to tidy the ruck up.

What about an idea if the referee awards a penalty for interference at the ruck, you just get a tap penalty instead of being able to kick to touch? Having an incentive of earning a free 40m, is what is causing players to try so hard to win a penalty by diving about. If you don'y actually get a any free ground, this could help combat it IMO.