Quote: Biff Tannen "If anything i would say Carney started off very good but has gradually been dragged down to the depths of the rest of the clowns that spout continuous nonsense throughout the match. I enjoy his segments with Wells though.
O'Connor, McDermott and Cummings are truly awful though most of the time but i guess we have to put up with them for the sake of live RL.'"
A few years ago Carney was very amateurish and came across like a fish out of water. His transformation into a proficient pundit has been one of the best imo, but I do know what you mean by getting dragged down - I think they get caught up with their own cliches and even start to believe half of what Stevo says!
I actually don't mind Barry Mac myself, he has his moments of decent commentary and quite a lot of useful insights, but he does make quite a few gaffs. As long as he's not trying too hard to be funny he's ok.
As for Cummings, he surprised me when he first entered the commentary box by providing some useful insights into decisions but he's gone so far downhill it's embarrassing. He's as bad as Stevo for making his mind up before he's seen a replay and he'll just say something like "yep, no evidence of a knock on there" when the video is clearly showing one. Pointless having him there anymore.