See this is the issue, the ref's mic clearly picked up him saying "shoulder to shoulder, no contact to the head, it's a knock on". Well you only need to view it once to realise that there definitely was contact to the head, and that can be further proved by the injuries sustained.

Regardless of whether the head was directly attacked (it was) any tackle that results in a player knocked out cold before he hits the floor, and needing a stretcher with a neck brace and an oxygen mask cannot be legal in this game. I hate the current shoulder charge rule as much as the next man, and I certainly don't want us to lose the last bit of biff in the game, but that incident was a straight red any day of the week - especially after 2 similar incidents have resulted in straight reds in the past few weeks

At the game, Monas was talking to him, from my view from the stand Thaler points to his ear and does the double hand signal for knock on, it was obvious he'd spoke to the vid ref in the crowd.
No one could believe we didn't get anything though, it was shocking and I was on the 10 line and the noise itself was something, then seeing him motionless was a little worrying to say the least.

rlThis may help.rl

If the rule is that any contact from the shoulder to the head is a red card, then that should have been a red card.

The 'nasty collision, injuries happen etc..' view I don't agree with. The Walmsley incident using that argument was a nothing tackle then as Walmsley was coming in with a bent back intending to make a legitimate tackle.

no charges from any weekend games so it was legit
good job he wasnt hanged from the hj crossbar at full time

rlLeuluai cleared of any foul play.rl