Makinsons a good player, good to watch. Not in the top tier of wingers in this country in my opinion, but a good player none the less.

I'm not sure that's correct. Players can and do knock on after the tackle is completed (such as when regaining their feet) and the ball being dead does not affect this.

By the letter of the law, it is correct. The evil "interpretation" is where the knock ons come from. For example, walmsleys knock on on the turn over vs castleford, by the letter of the law, wasn't a knock on (the ball wasn't in play) - but interpretation/ logic/ common sense says he shouldn't be rewarded for stupidity.

In this instance, the ball was dead, the player was injured. It was interpreted the injury affected the play (aka was the reason the knock on happened) and thus should just be a play the ball (just like players having to return to the point a tackle is completed now)

I think he's a decent winger. The one handed thing is good to watch, but how long will it be before the ball gets dislodged before he gets the ball down in a big game?. The diving over the line with both feet off the ground is a good tactic I think. If his legs are pushed toward touch they're well out of the way of the touch line.

Well it was to be expected. The thread was set up for yesterday's game.

Roby hardly played a blinder either. But there was no thread pre-game about Roby. Had there been I'm sure we would all be saying Roby is average when compared to Burrow.

Not a great game from any of the Saints lads. I'd fine it hard to pick a top 3 MOM for Saints yesterday. Amor I suppose being the exception.

A little embarrassing that so much is being made of what's basically a standard put down in this day and age. Nothing spectacular about how he finishes, at all.