Taumalolo was fantastic, absolutely rampant on that left edge.

I agree to an extent but I thought the Broncos goal line defence was excellent and they took their chances in attack well. The Dogs approach work was much less impressive, they looked hesitant and almost as if they'd all met just before kick off. Your point about the halfbacks for both teams is well made.

The Dogs have some great forwards yet their ball security was poor. I expect they'll get better. Will the Broncos? Barba slotted in well IMO.

The Warriors/Eels game was an anticlimax. V poor defence by Warriors, too many video replays. Not seen any of the other games yet.

One thing that has struck a chord with me over this weekend in the NRL, I'm absolutely hating how the shoulder charge is being interpreted - the game is being sanitised far too much.

I know it's an old arguement, but I really think the game will suffer if they stick with this clampdown on all things aggressive.

I get the need to punish head shots and to look after player welfare, but removing the legitimate shoulder charge tackle has taken away a part of the spectacle - I don't think it's a coincidence that since the hard line rules on shoulder charges and punching has been introduced, crowds in the NRL have dropped.

The players want the legitamate shoulder charge to stay and the fans generally want it to stay - why on earth have we dropped it. They site player welfare and the risk of litigation, but it's a risk associated with this sport - just like it's a risk associated with boxing or UFC (the fastest growing 'sport' in the world).

Glad to see it back, also, I like the zero tackle rule when the balls kicked dead. I know it’s only one extra tackle, but people might think twice about aimlessly booting it dead.

Game seems faster and less wrestle in the tackle with the new third man in rule. Def better. Crowds disappointing but TV audiences strong. Looks like NRL is going to be a sport for TV more and more.

The NRL is more interested in flogging bucket loads of KFC to it's armchair fans on Nine and Foxtel, hence the inordinate number of times decisions are being sent to the video ref. The Eels/Warriors fixture in particular was an absolute joke in that respect. Gotta get as many KFC ads in as possible.

The commentators mentioned the 3rd man rule as making the game quicker but Sterlo was quick to point out that this could just mean more dummy half scooting and less variation in the play. I’d argue that if the game becomes too quick in that respect then they should cut the distance between the sides from 10m to 8m.

Doubt that will happen though.

cynical as ever Bill!

Albert Kelly went further than any other player https://twitter.com/OptaJason/status/443198578320621568

Albert Kelly went further than any other player https://twitter.com/OptaJason/status/443198578320621568

NRL website seems to have ironed out most of the stats problems this week. quite like the timeline for each game which is a bit like a rlfans game thread without the bitching about attendances. superleague website needs a bit of a revamp i think - not a big fan of its current format

Melbourne v Penrith was a corker.

In the last 3 minutes alone there was 3 drop goals and a missed penalty kick on the 40m right on the hooter from penrith which would have won the game, instead they lost.

Expanding on bills point, why does the RFL not sell advertising rights for the big screen? They might as well take advantage of the fact every second decision seems to get referred, or have I missed something?