Quote Father Ted="Father Ted"The standard hasn't dropped due to franchising.
It has dropped because SL has gone from having 47% of its players from overseas to 17%.
The missing former NRL players have been replaced by young British players coming through from the academy system.
NRL players have usually played 150-250 games over there before they arrive here. They know their way around a Rugby League field.
Lads coming out of the academy are learning.
Are they as good as the NRL/SoO/Intl players we used to get.
Of course they are not but we have have to take the British players as the future of our game.
An example is Saints, at right centre they have gone from Jamie Lyon - Gidley - Shenton - Turner. Nothing could exemplify more the drop in standards than Lyon to Turner but Saints don't have a choice.
We can't get players of Lyon's calibre over here anymore.'"
The playing standards in SL have fallen for several reasons and the lack of overseas stars in SL is without a doubt another major contributory factor in that fall since 2008. The salary cap combined with the weakness of the UK currency in comparison to the Australian and Kiwi dollar are a couple of other major contributory factors.
However, you cannot dismiss the role of franchising, the increase from 12 to 14 teams, the 8 team play-off system and their overall effect on watering down the SL product and lowering the intensity. When the extra 2 teams were introduced into the SL franchising mix in 2009 and P&R was done away with, anyone with any sense knew it would weaken the overall playing standards of the competition - where teams were suddenly rewarded for their mediocrity via a Top 8 play-off system or rewarded with continued SL membership and no threat of relegation for being worse than mediocre.
It remains to be seen what effect the fall in domestic SL playing standards since 2008 has on England's performances and results during the World Cup in 2013. They were a total and utter embarrassment in 2008 and that was from a far healthier position in terms of domestic playing standards.