I don't normally comment on here, too many one eyed clowns. I can see why, with the number of replays shown from behind, that it looks obvious that the ball was grounded on the touch in goal line. However as stated above the ball is not square and there is one camera angle that was only shown once that seems to show that the POINT of the ball which is in Charnley's hand actually hits the try line before the rest of the ball hits the side line. It was more of a 50/50 call than the so called Wigan biased sky muppets wanted to indicate. The biggest problem as far as reffing went was the consistent holding down by Hull KR. They were smarter at it than Wigan because they mostly did it without putting a hand on the ball.
I was surprised the kick off by KR that resulted in a drop out and try was not looked at in more detail. It seemed to me that Taylor touched it before Smith. But maybe theres no mileage in saying the favourites were hard done to. More fun for sky to promote the story that the plucky underdog was undone by bad luck.

Is this what all the fuss is about? I was expecting something much worse.

Indeed. There is another thread entitled "worst decision ever". Some people need to get a grip.

Sure do, the 'worst decision ever' has got to be taking a naked picture in the mirror.

Tend to agree. That title still belongs to Ganson from the Magic weeekend with a million fancy cameras and every one the planet seeing the offside except Ganson.

This is simply inconsistant refereeing. The next disallowed try by Charnley should have been given.

More annoying was the team warning sin binning issue 10 sets and a half time later after it was issued. Totally stupid rule because it has no clear limits, as is the free play.

If the sin bin was for a dangerous tackle then a spear tackle ( O'Laughlin in the first half) is obvious classed as a legitimate tackle these days.

Inconsistant. Strange how it's got worse since Ganson became coach of the officials...

I assume you have missed the huge amount of irony of a Hull FC fan posting about a very dodgy VR decision against Hull KR.
Anyway crack on.