Why would it? It did no harm to James Maloney who is a fantastic player.

The Warriors have been unlucky so far, they are finding their feet and a lot better than their position suggests.

They've got Elliot as coach. They're as good as they are going to get!

That good, he is now at the Roosters.

Add into the equation Elliot is coaching them, need I go on?

Still better than going to Yawnion though.

Whats wrong with being @ the Roosters?

Why?
do you have to be in Aussie to reach your full potential?

Not being funny but this season we have seen some of Maloney's best ever form.

He deserves to be in the NSW squad this year he's been outstanding, and I'd agree certainly the best form I've seen from him over the past few seasons.

Nothing. That is my point. If he thought he could win things, he would have stayed and not gone to the Roosters.

I dont think its as a simple as that. Players leave clubs all the time a variety of reasons would be the cause of that rather than a player just thinking he can win things. Maloney had 2 good years at the warriors reaching one Grand Final and then decided to move back to NSW.

It isnt pretty much accepted that even if the Warriors were the #1 side in the competition for them its a lot harder as players dont generally want to go to Auckland. I'm pretty sure they have the backers to pay the wages but players will prefer to stay in NSW and Brisbane than go to NZ.

If Tomkins decided to go the the Warriors or anyone else for that matter it doesnt mean he would be at that one club forever regardless of who it is.