you just have cumbria vs south england as a curtain raiser to yorkshire vs lancashire, cumbria have plenty of super league player's with the likes of ben harrison, lee mossop, shaun lunt, kyle amor and ade gardner, and the south of england with louie mccarthy scarsbrook, darrell and josh griffin, tony club, kieron dixon and so on.

Yeah but the best players should play in the Lancs v York, as we want to make that our SoO. Actually Sam Tomkins was born down south wasn't he? Therefore on your account, he should play for the south? We should rig the game like the Aussies do with their SoO to make the best players avaliable to play against eachother, to improve our national team, by having an intense trial match to filter out the best players

i wouldn't be against that, i'd love to see a successful national team, and everything we can do to improve to be at the standard's of aussie's i'm all for, i believe we can produce just as good a 17 player's as the aussie's, i just think there's something mentally lacking, and that come's down to the standard of the two competition's and the lack of competative representive game's (on our part). i also love the rule of golden point in australia and would love to see it in our game, that's a mental test.

i think war of the roses is the rep game we need to doing straight away.

While I think history and heritage is important, Lancashire v Yorkshire is anachronistic and in my view is no basis for high-profile competition.

And there is no way that NRL-based players would fly over for it unless it became a big deal SOO type affair.

I'm more in favour of having a GB team, with the SOO (for want of a better term) being Celts v Saxons. Place of Birth could come into it, but any heritage system could work.

I understand the England A v England B, but it would face the same problem as a viewing competition that the exiles has. Which team do the fans pick and associate with. At least with a Saxons V Celts there is something to jump behind, with Exiles there is no fan attachement and the same goes for England B.

Lancashire and Yorkshire would be a bit too narrow for my liking. We need to open this out. With players like LMS and his cockney dulcit tones, he's not going to convice anyone he is Lancashire. But he would make a convincing Saxon.

It's traditional to have Lancashire and Yorkshire, and the facts are, the majority of SL players come from these 2 counties........ LMS could be an adopted Lancashire player? Like Rangi Chase is an adopted England player...... similar concepts.

The Aussie SoO has a hatred in it, to make it more intense. The same goes with Lancashire v Yorkshire, there is a kind of historical hatred which could make the game more intense