Quote: Madderzahatter "I can't believe this argument is still going! Ref got both decisions right (as all the replays showed) and the better team won. Simples...'"
the debate/discussion isn't over as if you go back to the original poster :
'fartown since 1961'
you will recall he/she remarked :
"Time Cummins was sacked and refereeing standards changed dramatically !!!"
so the debate is still alive and PopTart quite rightly saying that getting a couple of 50-50 calls wrong doesn't mean that "Rugby League no credibility left any more"
something has to be done though to make officials more uniform regarding consistency and working towards a more united interpretation of the rules - officials are too ambigous at the moment for whatever reason IMO