Quote Cronus="Cronus"Yes, you keep saying that but you ignore the reasons why the current England squad would also mostly be the GB squad, whereas in the past it would have been made up of several Welsh players and the odd Scottish and Irish player.'"
Several Welsh, Scottish and Irish players? Or several Yorkshiremen/Lancastrians with Celtic ancestry?
The only time we've had a significant of actual Welshman was when we could buy them in from RU. Everything after that has been a token Celt, and how many of them have changed allegiance?
Quote Cronus="Cronus"It's because, if they can qualify, all the best players now opt for England as the only competitive home nation, whereas in the past they could play for their home nation of origin while still having the option to compete for GB on tours and for the Ashes.'"
Like who? Which actual Welshmen/Irishmen/Scotsmen have switched allegiance? Not your McIllorums or your Harrisons or your Broughs. ACTUAL players from those countries that weren't just taking advantage of the fact that they could use Celtic nations as a feeder team for their actual country.
Quote Cronus="Cronus"That's precisely why having no GB weakens Wales, Scotland and Ireland, while essentially turning England into GB. Without the history and prestige GB holds, of course.'"
I think what would strengthen those nations is actual development work to bring in genuine players, and not just pretending they're doing well with a bunch of Aussies and Northern English with Celtic heritage. That's the problem. England aren't taking their players. They've been taking ours.