As we all know the RFL are onboard with this concept and are for the forseeable future. The reasoning behind this concept was to enable England to play 1 or 2 competitive matches against reasonable oppostion as the other host nations are seen as being too weak at present.

With the raise in the NRL cap the pool of decent Australian and NewZeland players is only going to shrink over the next 2/3 years. Is it not worth the RFL scrapping this concept now rather than allowing it to degrade due to lack of quality imports. And look at re establishing the War of the roses?

This was resurrected about 8 years ago i think and the interest for that was certainly higher than the interest in the Exiles game. The issue of players dropping out will probably be raised but if the RFL could get a sponsor for the contest and use that funding to pay players additional money for playing in the series as the Australians do in Origin it would counteract this problem. Also play them at better stadia Elland road and Etihad stadium for example this obsession we ahve of playing ganes ot traditional games does not generate external interest. I would also look to have a parallel series being ran between Cumbria and Cheshire if possible. These are areas of RL talent too.

IF they are to continue with the exiles games i cant for the life of me understand why they dont play a game in London what with all the Aussies and Kiwis Living in that area.

I know this concept would not enable the English team to play together but it would enable most players in contention for an england shirt to play against each other in a quality team against a quality team and see who fits best.

Constructive thoughts please......

these are 16/17/18 year old kids. Why take them to a different country, with a different language to stick them in a youth academy?

All i did was ask you a question, one which you seem to be avoiding whilst getting quite strangely protective of your 'idea', Why move the to England to do it when they can do it in France.

Do what in France? Train with various SL coaches? Train with International players and the best juniors in England? , play in the Championship ( a stronger comp than
the French Elite ) ?

Moving out of your ' comfort zone ' can quite often improve performance , it worked for a certain Scottish tennis player

These are academy players, not first team players. And yes, Toulouse can enter a side in SL academy to build towards there joining SL, they better ones who are physically ready can go on loan to the championship as they can now .

Drop the Knights tag for the purpose of this fixture and call it England v England, ala when you are playing FIFA with your mates. Okay we're not going to have clones of every player, but you get my drift.

Follow it with England v France in Perpignan, so long as France can draw their strongest side, which for a reason I never understand they never seem to do.

Exiles can also stay for mine, if it's a one-off.

Whatever side we end up playing mid-season I'd like us to start using those games to blood more youngsters in to the set up. The squad completely changes when the NRL contingent are added for the main comps so there isn't really an argument for continuity within the squad. I was just messing about earlier and put together a good, young English side.

Tomkins, 23
Charnley, 21
Watkins, 21
Arundel, 21
Briscoe, 22
Ratchford, 24
Lomax, 22
Mossop, 24
Clark, 19
Hill, 25
Farrell, 22
Bateman, 19
Westerman, 23

Taylor, 21
Patrick, 24
Whitehead, 23
McShane, 23

The only positions I really struggled with were the halves. I considered players like O'Brian, Myler, Smith and Sarginson but we really do struggle to produce top class halves in this country! That squad has an average age of just over 22 and would give the Exiles a decent game IMO. It would all be valuable experience as well.