How dare you suggest we keep him in the game. If we let good players stay how will the RFL succeed with their master plan to have Wakefield and Cas catch up? Kick him out I say. With players like that we'll never have an 'equal competition', and as many posters on here will tell you, an equal competition is the only way to grow the sport. Test all players regularly for excessive skill, strength or fitness. Anyone with too much of any must be banned for life. I'm sick of watching this talent ruin Nigel Wood's glorious game.

I agree. Some posts made in threads yesterday made some of these comments, but they seem to have disappeared off the forum. I have no idea why.

reed was excellent, widdop needs to start at 6 and not off the bench.

I'd agree in respect of Chase and Heighington; I thought Reed had a good game though and I see no reason he shouldn't keep his place.

As for Tomkins - I've been very critical of him in the past due to his niggly, house tactics; I thought he looked a significantly better player yesterday, when he seemed to be concentrating more on playing rugby and less on cheating. He lapsed into old ways briefly in the second half and decided to have a bit of handbags with the Aussie who had just played the ball and as a result, missed a cover tackle and a try was scored. Hopefully he'll learn something from that.

I'd bring Mossop into the team NOW if we are allowed to.
Widdop to stand off
Sinfield to the bench as interchange hooker
Carvell in for JJB or Wilkin

tomkins was sheer class.