Can you imagine what it would have been like if we had these kind of forums when Hanley, Edwards and Gregory were about? There would only be room for the threads started by opposition fans complaining about them!

You've posted some guff over the years but I reckon your ramblings on this thread are among your finest works.



Quality nonsense.

Get the excuses in early eh?

Hayne has done nothing special on the international scene and you cannot use him to make a point about Tomkins lack of impact

Scoring a try, setting up a try and having a fair try disallowed is nothing? in his last game against England is nothing?
You are starting to make England feel like France, you may be right.

Excuses for what?
Hayne will most likely not be picked for Australia this series

There was a player that played for a small Nation in the last World Cup, he almost carried his side on his own, that side came fourth in the World, that player destroyed France almost single handed.

That same player won the NRL player of the year 2 seasons ago, he had the biggest impact of a single player for his team in recent memory winning games almost single handed to drive his team into the Grand Final.

Tomkins has done nothing at all at the top level, against St George in the WCC he was shut down, his highlight was a Headbutt and knees in the back of Morris after he had scored his Try.,

Do you think you are doing a fair comparison by using Tomkins solitary appearance in a pre-season friendly and comparing it with a field of performance that encompasses one World Cup and one season in the NRL?

So that's worse than your tactic of quoting people to death. You do realise you are legendary for it, but not in a good way. I've said all I need to say, never said you or anyone else had to agree. People like you and Wellsy love to pretend you are on here to debate - but you're not. Your minds are made up and you're only wish is to browbeat. Your attempts to dress it up as some pseudo intellectual exercise is utterly transparent.

Mate, you are busted.

As soon as you start using disallowed tries as an argument for international success you know you are on a losing wicket

Jarryd Hayne has scored 5 tries in 10 test matches (three of which were for Fiji) and Sam Tomkins has scored 7 tries in 8 test matches and yet you are using Jarryd Hayne as a comparator to show how Tomkins is ‘not on the international radar’ at this point in his career

So, to sum up... Tomkins is younger than Hayne, played less test matches and scored more tries. A perfect example of how Hayne proves Tomkins is not on the international radar

Do you really think that is a compelling argument?

You're wrong, end of

Just watching the highlights of Saints Salford – Graham was all class when he threw his toys out the pram after having a try disallowed and got sin binned for dissent (he couldn't have timed it better for you!)

Another world beating performance from young ratboy today in another big game.

As i said earlier, i bet the Aussies are cr@pping it.