Quote: J. Willard Gibbs "
I just pointed out that your refutation was only valid in the case of no air resistance. Your references to the force required was purely i the context of getting the ball up to that velocity as you passed it, not what happened
'"
Not true, I actually changed my wording so that that would not be the case - "mass would only effect the required force to get it to that speed and in that direction".
Just because I didn't make clear what was applying the force doesn't change the fact I didn't exclude air resistance.