Yeah he is.

And of course, you have greater credibility and knowledge than Nathan Brown.

Donno is no different this year to how he was before injury. The same lightweight plodder that doesnt break a tackle, make a line break or put anybody through a gap. Ive found the claim of him being some kind of prodigy or wonderkid dubious well before his injury.

Donno was outstanding last year before he got injured, and thats not the opinion of just myself - but sorry every other professional to do with rugby league must not know what they are talking about either ??

Outstanding?

Youre having a laugh.

Mediocre.

Again that is your opinion

yes he is. no he isnt. blah blah blah. Surely when arguing against a concensus the opinion of somebody with more credentials than you, a good starting ooint is some evidence or reason.

your honour, that dna evidence from the highly acclaimed expert is rubbish. why, and on what grounds do you say that bulls4champs2010???? because its true. and what makes you so sure. because im right!

Indeed.

I don't think he's crap but he needs to develop more of a passing game. It's obvious what he's going to do, straight run forward.

a few facts, ie Donnos stats. 12 played last season, 11 this. metres per carry last season 7 this 5 missed tackles % 6.6% both seasons tackle busts 6 this 10 last more penalties more errors this season. So not as good stats this season as last. his problem is hes neither a Langley nor an Addy type of LF when you compare his stats with them, hes sort of inbetween.

so thats the stats, but what does he bring to the team that doesnt show itself in the stats?

anothe half ?? have you not got enough of them ? where are they all going to play

Donaldsons crap!?? Get a grip. The lads 19 FFS.

I'm sure the idiots moaning that he's crap are also on the other thread moaning about letting players like Larne Patrick, Ryan Atkins go as well. Don't underestimate how much that injury effected him, plus he has also been in and out of the team this year.

As Adey said Jamie Peacock was 21 before he started to come good.

Some fans expect players to be world class at stupid ages. He's 19!!!

OK, he's not a world beater at the moment, but why would you expect him to be. He's got years ahead of him to improve and develop.

And this is coming from the prat who thought we should have let Kearney go and sign Elliott Kear from crusaders. You are seriously deluded!

agreed 100%

When Peacock was braking through he had few half decent players in front of him.