Harsh!

Don't talk wet. He's a rough gem. He's had some good games, some not so good ones, but what do you expect from a young lad in his debut season?

Agreed, we shouldn't be giving young lads so much stick (Donaldson included). Experienced players should be doing more imo.

Nah Donno isnt a rough Gem.

Raynor is a testimony to the famous shirt adored by all us fans.

I hope you read this Gaz, or someone at the club does, because amongst the shower, you're a reason to be proud.

Very touching, Aaron.

Very boring, B4C2010.

You see, I don't come on here to slate everyone like our best players, unlike you.

Not been a fan in recent years but he bust a gut last night. I thought Sibbit tried his nuts off again to little effect. In the first couple of minutes the brilliant Leuluai made a half gap & O'Loughlin was right there on his shoulder. On the next Bradford set Sibbit made a half break & there was no-one within cooee for mine.

poor poor effort if that idiot is ur best player.
you lads where terrible last night, uve gone backwards with potter

I think that's a fair bit bit over the top. That said, much as Tom has done well in (what's let's not forget) his debut season, despite what many others have said, I thought last night was probably one of his least effective performances. Youngster not at his best against the champions shock!! Read all about it!!

I do think his name brings him far more attention than someone of his age (and ability) might normally get, but you can't blame him for that, and he's earning his spot in the side with his performances, for my money there's no doubt he would still be included in the team even if his name [iwere[/i Jack Jones.

What a stupid comment. I agree with you about his fitness. But the offloading and passing is a ridculous comment to make. Each drive he makes he makes well over 10m drawing in at east 3 tacklers. That is what you want from your props. He is not a stand off. The offload skill will probably come as he gets older. At 6ft 4, i doubt he ever needed to offload at junior level as he probably just bust through teams all the time.

What do you want, a player who drives at least 10m with 3 tacklers around him. Or a player who runs 5m to the defnsive line, offloads and then we either knock on or lose momentum.

tbh id rather he be a bit more conservative with his offloads and not compulsive like lynch.

How could anyone argue with such an articulate and well thought out post?

No lack of bad winners this weekend.