I'll tell you if that's right this time next year...

Theres a video of Purtell dropping the ball / errors (theres only 4 and to be honest on one he is taken out in the air) but theres also a video of a good take and good finish under pressure - can't post it though.



hmmm.....if thats all you have to say don't bother, perhaps explain why you think this?

How is it an embarressment? Other teams are signing players / NRL rejects who are wife beaters, dog fiddlers and driving offenders.

Not had chance to watch the video but not overly concerned if he only makes 4 mistakes on it. Must still be an improvement on Ah Van. If they made a video of his mistakes this season it would be available in a box set.

Although it should really be

Well Purtell doesn't exactly come highly recommended does he but he'll find it easier in SL.

What makes you think that? Connor made point of describing him as a three quarter rather than a which suggests he could feature at or wing. Penrith fans seem to think he shouldn't be allowed anywhere near a spot. Bit of wishful thinking there, maybe because seems to be more of a weakness in the squad than wing.

Just a little point... Conner is not a coach he barely has any rugby league knowledge and expertise. He is a reporter and dies just that, reports what he's been told and that's it. Conner wouldn't know what position this guy played if he wasn't told

The guy has been holding down a regular centre spot and we are weak in the centres. This should suggest he ll be good enough to hold down a spot

I think Murphy has played a bit of league. To suggest he wouldnt know what poition one plays without being told is pants of the highest order. He's a RL reporter for frick sake.

When I was on about the position, I was saying that he probably didn't know Purtell existed untill he was told last week we might be signing him, so he wouldn't know what position he played

Why wouldnt he know of him?

TBH i dont think you should rely too much on what other teams fans have to say about a player he may come to Bradford with a different attitude and change his playing style, he hasnt looked bad from what ive seen off him, and in saying that the same goes for Ah Van he may be pap for us but may go to Widnes and have a belting few seasons.........

.... I suppose we will just have to wait til 2012 to see what Purtell is really like !!!

And he's a good composer too

Sort of suggests otherwise?

Just a little point...have you spoken with Connor at all? To be able to back up what you said?

Connor has always seemed decent enough in his RL knowledge. Though I get the idea that his views are no more valuable than most on here. Doesn't he come from a football background in reporting.

Have to wait and see on this purtell.