1.

Some very ordinary players have appeared in Grand Finals and Cup Finals ,yet some great have never had any honours , John Woods being one ,having graced the Leigh,Warrington,and Bradford teams never playing at Wembley yet some have been to Wembley many times.

I would have Gaskell in my team ahead of Brierley all the time. Brierley is a pretty decent player playing in a very good team where as Gaskell is an excellent player playing in a pretty average team.

Brierley a decent player have a word with yourself ,look at his speed , ball handling skills try scoring, he can kick goals ,given the choice between the 2 I would have Brierley in the Fax team anytime, unfortunately it won't happen.

An interesting debate here ,no doubt Gaskell is a very good player but add injury prone to his other undoubted talents , for me Ryan B will put on a show to convince you of his on Sunday.

He's not injury prone, he had his jaw broken by being smashed in the face off the ball with an elbow.

I agree an injury like this cannot be helped , but he did have a lot of minor injuries when he was at Saints.Again I'm not doubting his playing talents though.

Charlie knows.......

...bugger all

Greg maybe he is a big fish in a small pond? I rate Gaskell but saints wouldn't of let him go if he was so good!! I still wouldn't mind him at Leigh mind!! Haha

Thats probably why Saints let Matty Smith go? I can see your logic

Lee Briers was a pretty useless halfback too!

Exchanged for Paul Sculthorpe. I think Saints got the better deal.

I aren't sure Briers was a swap for Sculthorpe

No he wasn't.