Please don't let him near the ball tonight.

Where did it all go wrong with Platt ??

Remember his tries vs Warrington at the HJ in 2007 ????

Unlucky, according to the T&A he's playing left centre.

How can people think that Platt is better than Halley ?

I'd rather have Gail Platt than Michael Platt

both cack

Halley isn't. He's still learning and he did well under so much pressure.

Halley was awful tonight.

You're kidding right? He was f'ing terrible tonight!

Would Platt have done any better?

Oh and these were also awful:

Sykes
Jeffries
Langley
Tadulala
Scruton
Kopzcak

I thought Kopzcak was one of the better ones, to be fair he's one of the only players getting better this season rather than worse.

Crookes and Nero were hopeful before the injuries.


Rhinoms - I didn't think Cook and Menzies were awful, as for Burgess he did a Jeffries on us, where the f**k did he go?

Halley had a mare tonight, as did everyone else though. but when he brings the ball back, he will never ever beat anyone, although platt do the odd silly thing, he is more threatening with ball in hand. i think in the long run we will see platt at FB, and halley on the wing, as sheriffe is dogmeat.

If you can bring yourself to watch it again mate watch how menzies and cook defend
Also cook conceded a few penalties that led to tries.