Sorry, that was mischievous of me...

Sorry to bring this up if it's already been mentioned elsewhere (And I'm pretty sure at least one person will have done so).

What are everyone's feelings on the top try scorer in SL being a Bulls player at a different club?
surely we wouldn`t be where we were if he was with us currently?
Or have Wakey had a much easier start to the season?

I hate playing Devil's advocate... But I'd love to know people's opinions on this.

How do you work that out? Would he have prevented the Wigan rout?
Or stopped KR getting the drop goal?
I think that's a very sweeping generalisation.
Halley is not the Messiah....

I don't think it would have made any difference if he had played with us from the start of the season, one player would not have changed our results, it was how our team was playing as a whole which was the problem.

That said I'm glad to have him back in the squad, he offers another option and that can only be a good thing, wonder whether he will start on Sunday.

Agreed. By his own admission being loaned out gave him a kick up the backside. He also admitted that his preparation going into the season wasn't as good as it should have been. It is far from certain he would have shown such good form if he hadn't have been sent away to get himself up to speed. If anything the loan out probably gave him the extra push he needed.

No... I'm just trying to get an idea of what people think.

...He is however, a VERY naughty boy!

Good stuff.

I hadnt heard that.

So, thanks!

All I can say after that win is . . .

Halley-lujah

Sorry to pee on everyone's bonfire, but Halley isn't top try scorer.

Shaun Ainscough at Wigan has 6.

I agree, I think its [ibecause [/ihe was loaded out that he had such good form, (point to prove and all that) and so you can't say he would have played like that had he been with us still. He needs to keep pushing on now and no doubt he'll be involved again at the weekend.

I think its just an individual award rather than who he is or has played for during the season.

I think thats correct, and if he keeps his place in the 17 he's got to have a chance.

Always one party pooper !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes and err... No.