Neither PTB would have passed muster back in the day but in this day and age as long as the tackled player has previously got back onto two feet, the "ball playing" foot doesn't seem to need to touch the ball. If anything, Hingano's foot might have touched it - just!

Regarding the "forward" pass, this blasted momentum rule seems to have really muddied the waters. Who the heck knows anymore? Back on the 1st of April (of all days), Leigh nilled Dewsbury by 44 with the visitors having a sole score chalked off for a forward pass. Bongser was sitting next to Charlie Caroli, virtually square on to the pass, and we both thought that the try should have stood - and a good one it would have been too.

Only seen the highlights and therefore can't comment on Walker's disallowed effort or on Pauli x2.

Onward to 'Haven at home.

Forward passes are always a problem for refs to rule on as angles can be very deceptive and the ref may be looking at them from the front or rear so is relying on the touch judge who may also be unsighted.

So long as the ball comes out of the hands sideways or backwards it doesn't matter if the player catching it is in front of the passer - that's basically how I see it. There used to be a well known try that illustrates this perfectly (well it does for old fogeys that remember it) - Joe Lydon scoring for GB against the Kiwis in 1985. It's one of the all time classics. Hanley makes a break down the touchline, throws a hopeful ball inside and Lydon catches it in front of where Hanley passed.

Rugby Union appears to remain extremely generous about forward passes even at international level. Every time I watch a union game I see tries scored that would be chalked off in League. Ironically for a sport clogged in rules, their mentality is that if its there or there abouts, let the game flow.

The passing movement that led to the famous Gareth Edwards try for the Barbarians vs the All Blacks in 1973 included a pass that went about 3m forward but nobody mentions it. Fair enough. RL fans in particular will always find fault no matter what.

Going back some (all too many) years also, Bongser was at his college halls of residence and watching a Five Nations (as it was then) game involving Scotland (probably vs England) and the Scots captain Gavin Hastings loosed (literally) a pass from within the 22m line that was caught well beyond it. The resulting try was shown several times with praise from Nigel Starmer-Smith - never a word against the officiating. Think it's drummed into these RU silver spooners from an early age that, should they dare to do that, Nanny will come round and spank them AND NOT IN A NICE WAY!

Pauli Pauli 1 match ban. It doesn't affect us and I known disciplinary is very hard to get consistency, but considering most neutrals were saying it was a straight red, how they've come up with a 1 game ban beggars belief.

Dont get used to it you chumps are coming back down to earth this week when you loose at home to white haven.

Another 2 points this weekend and are top 3 spot is almost secure. How the tables av turned and the mighty av fallen you should of spent money on players instead of foam fingers

TBH I'm happy with that as I would have been if he'd had a red and it was taken as sending off sufficient. Can't wait to see Ford's comments on it.

The Aaron Murphy ban seems harsh mind.

The troll (and I say that loosely because it's one of the most feeble I've come across) is now banned.

Trust me, you were born to do it!

Good man PP although that will have only fed his anti bradford agenda.

‘They dint sign mi and they car the tel da banta innit’

Hope he doesn’t take it out in his sister.

If by some miracle we put in a similar heroic performance to York away and manage to get one over on fax please can we unban him for 24/7 to get his views ha

If Pumper promises an "unban" for even a couple of days, Dunning should nail the announcement to the shed wall - Bradford by a country mile:

"Us wam robed"

"Reff wam bi-d"

"Cheetin theefs"

It would be glorious and compulsive reading for two or three days - and then send him to Coventry again.