there are 3 players not mentioned the best scrum half both Bradford +Gt Britain Tommy Smales, best winger Jack McLean, and one of the great all time players who seemed to be frozen out by some of his teammates Shaun Edwards.
my selection would be
1- Keith Mumby
2- Jack McLean
3- Paul Newlove
4- Shontayne Hape
5- Les Vainikolo
6- Henry Paul
7- Tommy Smales
8- Kelvin Skerrett
9- Jimmy Lowes
10- Brendan Hill
11- Daniel Gartner
12- Karl Fairbank
13- Ellery Hanley
subs
14- Shaun Edwards
15- Keith Fielden
16- Brad McKay
17- Steve Menzies
Unfortunatly most people never saw Tommy Smales but he controlled almost every game he played with his ball skills,football brain and ability to make a break, down the years we've had some good scrum halves but I would'nt include deacs and seaborne amongst them, I did like Dean Carrol, Ken Kelly,Paul Harkin,Alan R?(brother David both GB ) the lad from hull(via Tunisia great ball player) and of course Robbie Paul.

Withers
Vaikona
Naylor
Hape
Vainikolo
Henry
Robbie
Vagana
Lowes
Fielden
Peacock
Gartner
Bradley

Anderson
McD
Burgess
Forshaw

What are peoples thought process here. Individual talent or how they think they'll play as a team? Surprised by the Naylor shouts. Good player and don't have anything against him but I think he looked better than he was playing in a fantastic team. If Paul Sykes played centre in that team I think he would have been a big success. Naylor never really did anything with his other teams which might be more of an indication. Naylor better than Newlove or Danny peacock? Just confused, that's all.

IMO For us Naylor was outstanding, better than Newlove was for us and probably gave us better service than Peacock although not as talented as either.

Fair enough. If that's your thought process why isn't Radford in the side? Did a fantastic job for us and helped us win loads of trophies. Did a far better job for us than Bradley did. Bradley mainly played centre and stand off for us. Didn't do a fantastic job at loose forward.

I was just thinking ability.

Yeah true, and I almost put Radford in.

If it's the greatest BULLS 17 mine would be
1. Withers
2. Vaikona
3. Danny Peacock
4. Hape
5. Vainikolo
6. Henry Paul
7. Robbie Paul
8. Big Joe
9. Lowes
10. Fielden
11 Gartner
12. Peacock
13. Forshaw
14. Brian Mcdermott
15. Andy Lynch
16. Dwyer
17. Graeme Bradley

Micheal Withers

Leslie Vainokolo
Shontayne Hape
Graham Bradley
Tevita Vaikona

Henry Paul
Robbie Paul

Stuart Fielden
James Lowes
Joe Vagana

Karl Fairbank
Jamie Peacock
Mike Forshaw

Mat Orford
Shaun Edwards
Micky Higham
Patrick Ah Van

Tried to omit Northern Players as it said "Greatest BULLS 17 of my time"

In my time as a Bradford RL fan then it would be

Keith Mumby

Gerald Cordle
Paul Newlove
Graham Bradley
Leslie Vainokolo

Henry Paul
Paul Harkin

Jeff Grayson
James Lowes
Kelvin Skerret

Karl Fairbank
Jamie Peacock
Ellery Hanley

Paul Medley
Dave Watson
Derycke Fox

1. Keith Mumby
2. Berwyn Jones
3 Darral Shelford
4 Paul Newlove
5 Lionel Williamson
6 John Woods
7 Robbie Paul
8 Kelvin Skerret
9 Keith Bridges
10 Stuart Fielden
11 Bill Pattinson
12 Karl Fairbank
13 Bob Haigh
14 Ellery Hanley
15 Henry Paul
16 Graham Joyce
17 Colin Forsyth

Tough one. Will go wiv;
1. Robbie Paul
2. Tevita Viakona
3. Leon Pryce
4. Shontayne Hape
5. Les Vainikolo
6. Henry Paul
7. Paul Deacon
8. Stu Fielden
9. Jimmy Lowes
10. Paul Anderson
11. Jamie Peacock
12. Glenn Morrison
13. Jamie Langley
14. Mick Withers
15. Joe Vagana
16. Sam Burgess
17. Steve Menzies
Would love to see this team running out at Odsal in 2012 haha

1. Halley
2. McAvoy
3. Platt
4. Ah Van
5. Sheriffe
6. Sykes
7. Herbert
8. Feather
9. Pratt
10. Moore
11. Rigon
12. Hall
13. Swann

I would have put money on Lesley being on everyone's list before this.

1 Dave Watson
2 TV
3 Paul Newlove
4 Hape
5 Big Les
6 Henry Paul
7 Robbie
8 Big Joe
9 Jimmy
10 Baloo
11 Menzies
12 Fairbank
13 Brad Mckay

Subs
14 Leon
15 Sam Burgess
16 Paul Medley
17 Stuart Fielden

Redfearns and Bak Diabera

Never saw Les play so I didn't put him in. Now I realise I don't think I saw Fielden play either so its Forsyth into the starters and Ramsey on the bench.