Widdop
Briscoe
Shenton
Atkins
Hall
O'Loughlin (I have to agree with GB, Brown isn't good enough)
Tomkins
Graham
Robinson
Fielden
Burgess
Ellis
Harrison

Roby
Crabtree
Carvell
Westwood

Yes, hence why it's not in HD, because the BBC can't be @rsed with HD when it comes to RL. So far they've shown a whole ONE game in High Def, and yet have shown lower league football in it. (Whereas Sky show every Super League, International, NRL Final & Origin game in HD).

Sooner we get away from the BBC, the better IMO. It's just another example that they don't care enough to give the sport the proper respect.

Not great when you're used to watching in beautiful HD. The BBC's coverage is appalling.

As good as HD is, it doesn't get rid of Jonathan Davies squeaky, inaccurate spoutings.

Perhaps the picture will distract me from this..

Let's hope so.

Dave Woods is equally poor.

RL coverage is appalling in the UK. Scott Donald's recent assessment of Sky in particular upon his departure from the country was spot on.

Eddie is like the cringeworthy mate everyone seems to have who pretends to know about sport, tries to join in the conversation, reads the odd headline but inherently, knows nothing.

Stevo has become a parody of himself and his assessment of games is way off beam.

Phil Clarke lost his credibility with his "injury" comment along with him repeatedly drawing one off at anything or anyone Wigan-centric.

Sky's coverage on a Thursday night of Co-Op games is SO much better. Bill Arthur, Terry O'Connor & Barrie Mac make a far better commentary team. I'd love to see them promoted to doing the Super League matches instead.

But even Eddie, Stevo & Phil come across as brilliant compared to the BBC clowns. There's only Clare Balding who's anywhere near decent on BBC and that's more down to enthusiasm for the game than it is for knowledge. The fact they continue with dross like Ray French & Jonathan Davies is another example of them not giving a toss.

A combination of Brian Carney, Terry & Barrie would be best imo.

Absolutely.

Brian Carney is an excellent summariser. By far the best around.

He is very good.

I also think Robbie & Iestyn do a good job on the BBC.

You were doing so well until then



Robbie isn't great "live", stutters a little too much and his brain thinks faster than he is able to project to the audience.

Iestyn could talk a glass eye to sleep.