Addy has done well for us in the absence of a recognised scrum half but he is not a scrum half. He is too slow around the ruck and tends to send out lobbed passes which gives the opposition time to move up. Remember Brett Iti? he passed the ball from the scrum (there more scrums then) like a bullet so much so that the pass nearly knocked Roger Simpson (the stand off) over. Perhaps now that Warrington have a plethora of half backs we may sign Gareth O'Brien next season? Addy would slot in a loose forward but I think he needs to work on his defence.

69 of his 116 appearances he has started at either 6 or 7. He has only started in the back row 11, 12 or 13 on 21 occasions.

Bloody hell, that's way more than I would have guessed.

Not really... He's been at half back more or less all this season, and as far as I recall it was much the same story last year.

This kinda backs up my reason for starting this thread. People keep saying 'Addy is really a loose forward' but there comes a point when you have to say 'if he walks like a duck, and talks like a duck....'

Yeah, I suppose. It has always felt like a temporary measure though. It's just a temporary measure that's never really gone away.

...
...then you need to take more water with it, until it just sounds like quacking again.