Think you are a bit harsh guys you have been busted most of season with injuries and have had 3 really tough fixtures. I thought tonight was a terrific effort and i hope that silenced the Pies who think Micky Thug Mac is better than Roby . Any team who have the injuries that Saints have had would not have done any better . Obviously you need Cas to lose not just for the L.L.S but also to avoid Wigan next week

Brown is a simple-minded idiot. Remember that.

Anyone surprised? Another awful performance tonight. Roby and LMS were outstanding, a few of the outside backs did what they could, but for me most of that 17 and coaching staff can bugger off.

Brown has got to go. Huddersfield were worse off than we were for injuries and yet we still let them bully us. Our pack is pathetic, utterly pathetic. Walmsley was stupid and we again didn't deserve to win. Yet the tool still comes out and tells them he's proud of them. They did okay, he likes okay and Eamon loves it, as it's cheaper than excellent.

It was a charge down but wasn't the ball then picked up by a player in an offside position...

Can't be offside from a charge down, it should have been play on with saints in possession.

As soon as it hits a Huddersfield player, all saints players are onside.

Jinx

Lms would have scored with the play on call imo.

Wellens
Dawson
Turner
Hohiah
Flanagan
LMS
Laffranchi
Masoe
Manu
Soliola
Wilkin

I'd not loose any sleep to see thw whole lot gone for next year. Replaced by 2 class players and the rest promote youngsters.

Brown, Lolesi, Cunningham andmost of all Joey Heyes. Get shut and a new team in.

I agree, leave LMS out of that list though.

You can't be serious. I'd lose sleep cause we'd have about 11 players on the team.
I agree we need a strength and conditioning coach the like that Wigan & Leeds have and maybe to ship 2/3 of those players but that post is ludicrous.

It raises a more general question of how our squad will shape up next year though. I can only hope our silence in the player market is because were quietly beaveri away at specialist off field staff ...

I agree but you can't lose that many players and expect to compete, getting Burns in to partner Walsh is a great move and Vea will add size. Who we lose/sell is critical to where we end up next season.

Our youngsters have proved time and time again they can step up. Leeds at home etc.. just because they're not experianced players does not make them a poorer option. For example i'd take Richards, Thompson, Savelio and Greenwood over Laffranchi any day of the week.

2 or 3 top class SL players and we would be laughing. Take them players away and add the likes of Todd Carney and Willie Tonga (who have both signed for Catalans) and Hock into our pack and we would'nt be far off.

Fair enough- from where I was sat it looked like it had hit a few players - just watched it back in tv and Taai doesn't play at that-the ball hits his shoulder- but you know what. Karma is a bitch!