Where do people get this idea from that Catalans where boring ? They always played off the cuff under Potter from what i seen!

exactly, it suits SaintsFans agenda to assume that, but they didn't!

No, we are boring! Catalans were a big pack, and still are a big pack, and are known for going up the middle. We are not a big pack and we are not as effective going up the middle.

And Catalans sometimes could be very boring. Sometimes, if Bosc was on form, they could be very spontaneous. But also they could just play relatively boring up the middle rugby.

Translation = that is SaintsFan's opinion.

it shows how little you know. while potter was there everything revolved around Mogg, McGuire and Greenshields. Once catalans reverted back to this game plan in the latter half of the season then they were much more effective.

Still does doesn't it?

fancy reading the part after the bit you bolded?

Well, since we were discussing Catalans off the cuff play then I think my comment about Bosc was spot on since he can be an off the cuff player. Loved his try against whoever when he kicked once from each foot and scored. That should have had a trophy all to itself. I'd love to see that kind of skill and spontenaity more often in the Superleague.

Shame our first choice 7 wasn't up to producing that kind of quality at all this season though. A situation that had nothing to do with Potter...

i have. One trophy less than us

I wondered how long it would be...!!

There's always a wire nearby to whip and schlong the challenge cup in your face.

They're like a poor mans Spanish Inquisition

How do you know?

I'm not saying that it was anything to do with Potter but I'd like to know how you can assert that it wasn't. Unless you join the lads in their training sessions and such like?

Only away from home, when playing in france they are consistently more creative and play with considerably more flare.

Their hand is forced somewhat away from home. Teams traditionally are required to play much more defensive, not just in RL.



At the start of the year our forward line would have consisted of Graham, Cayless, Fas'avalu, Hargreaves/Puletua and Cunningham, thats a pretty big pack if you ask me.

Our hand was forced when by losing Cayless and Fas'avalu early in the year for a large part of the comp, and though Puletua is big enough for the front line and has chipped in, for me, he has more impact in the 2nd row. Add to this the fact that Hargreaves has about as much impact at prop as a bug on a car windshield and you begin to understand why we have struggled playing it up the middle this season.

What I feel has hurt us this year is that when we have taken the ball up the middle or ability to offload has completely disappeared, this was something that set the two teams apart in the final and to a degree in the semi too. Unfortunately Cayless was perhaps our best exponent of this art in our pack.

Well, I've only seen them playing away as I've yet to afford a visit to their place (unfortunately, as I'd love to go).


I think this was more what I was thinking of, rather than simply size. They are generally a bigger group of players physically than Saints but also they seem to make real progress when they go forward because their pack appears to do stuff with the ball. So perhaps I should have added more effective along with bigger.